The recent closure of BioWare and cancellation of Mass Effect 5 has led to a contemplation of what might have been for the storied RPG developer. As CD Projekt Red continues to support and expand its decade-old titles like The Witcher 3, questions arise about whether BioWare could have found a more secure path by developing expansions for its beloved franchises rather than struggling with new, ambitious projects.
CD Projekt Red's commitment to its games is evident through continuous updates and expansions. The Witcher 3, originally released in 2015, is set to receive its third expansion, "Songs of the Past," in 2027. This is in addition to the game's remaster and the substantial updates and DLC for Cyberpunk 2077, including the Phantom Liberty expansion and the Edgerunners Season 2 update. This long-term support strategy not only engages existing fans but also attracts new players to these worlds.
In contrast, BioWare's final years were marked by lengthy, troubled development cycles and products that failed to meet expectations. The studio's pivot to live-service games, beginning with Anthem, proved disastrous. Anthem, after a difficult launch in 2019, was eventually shut down, with its development tools and approach influencing other projects. Dragon Age: The Veilguard, initially conceived with live-service elements, underwent significant retooling before its eventual release. Even with its single-player focus, the game has been described as being "at war with itself," struggling to balance concluding existing story arcs with introducing new elements.
Fans have speculated that an approach similar to CD Projekt Red's could have benefited BioWare. The Mass Effect Legendary Edition, released in 2021, could have served as a platform for new, episodic content, offering fresh missions and expansions that would have kept the series in the public consciousness. Such an approach might have provided a more consistent revenue stream and a clearer development path, potentially averting the studio's eventual closure.
The cancellation of Mass Effect 5, alongside the studio's shuttering, leaves a significant void in the RPG landscape. The legacy of BioWare, known for its rich storytelling and memorable characters, is now overshadowed by its recent struggles. While EA's role in the studio's fate is a subject of ongoing discussion, the missed opportunity to build upon established successes with focused expansions remains a point of poignant reflection for many in the gaming community. The possibility of a future for BioWare, perhaps under new ownership, hinges on learning from these past challenges and rediscovering the strengths that once defined the studio.