Denis Villeneuve’s 'Dune: Part 3' is set to conclude a highly successful adaptation of Frank Herbert’s seminal space opera on December 16th. While David Lynch’s 1984 'Dune' has a cult following, Villeneuve’s interpretation has achieved greater commercial and critical success, staying largely faithful to the source material’s characters and themes. However, before Villeneuve’s vision took shape, Ridley Scott was once slated to direct an adaptation.

Early Attempts at Adaptation

The rights to Herbert's novel attracted Hollywood attention early on. Producer Arthur P. Jacobs optioned the rights in 1972, but after his death, French producer Jean-Paul Gibon led a new attempt in 1974, bringing in filmmaker Alejandro Jodorowsky. Jodorowsky’s surrealist style was a departure, and his ambitious production, which included casting his young son as Paul Atreides and offering Salvador Dalí a high hourly rate, ultimately collapsed due to budget constraints. This failed attempt was later documented in the 2013 film 'Jodorowsky's Dune.'

Scott’s Vision and H.R. Giger’s Influence

Following 'Star Wars,' Ridley Scott became interested in directing science fiction. He was recruited by producer Dino De Laurentiis in 1976 to direct 'Dune.' Scott was introduced to the work of Swiss artist H.R. Giger by writer Dan O’Bannon, with whom Scott would later collaborate on 'Alien.' Giger had already created designs for Jodorowsky's 'Dune,' including concepts for the Harkonnen castle and a sandworm that bore a resemblance to the Xenomorph from 'Alien.' Scott envisioned a distinct visual style for his 'Dune,' with Arrakeen depicted as a medieval fortress surrounded by a water-scarce city, featuring elements like barroom brawls and characters with multiple breasts, an idea later seen in 'Total Recall.'

Script Disagreements and Project Collapse

Herbert himself wrote a script for Scott’s version, intending it as a two-part film. However, Scott found it too faithful and light on action, wanting to retain only a few scenes. He sought a new script, first approaching Harlan Ellison, who declined, and then collaborating with novelist Rudolph Wurlitzer. Herbert was critical of the new script, particularly its suggestion of an incestuous relationship between Paul and his mother, Jessica, and the simplification of characters, merging Gurney Halleck with Duncan Idaho and Jamis’ wife Harah with Chani.

A Divergence to a Masterpiece

The production faced significant hurdles. De Laurentiis estimated Scott’s 'Dune' would cost $50 million (nearly $300 million today), proposing a cost-saving production in Mexico City, which Scott found unappealing. Furthermore, Scott was not ready to commit to the project's lengthy production schedule, especially after the death of his brother, Frank, in 1980. Scott eventually left 'Dune,' and De Laurentiis hired David Lynch. Lynch’s film, released in 1984, was both a commercial and critical disappointment. Scott, meanwhile, turned his attention to adapting Philip K. Dick's 'Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?,' resulting in the critically acclaimed science fiction masterpiece 'Blade Runner.' This shift allowed Scott to create a lasting legacy in the genre, a path that ultimately paved the way for Villeneuve's successful 'Dune' adaptations.