The Game Awards nominations have been announced, sparking debate over which titles were overlooked. While blockbuster releases often dominate the Game of the Year (GOTY) conversation, many critically acclaimed games have missed out on a nomination despite their significant impact and lasting legacy. This year's nominations saw 'Grand Theft Auto 6' lead the pack, but the absence of several notable indie and AAA titles from the GOTY race highlights a recurring theme: the industry's highest honor isn't always bestowed upon games that resonate most deeply with players or critics.
Dark Souls 3
FromSoftware's 'Dark Souls 3' offered a polished and somber conclusion to its acclaimed trilogy. By refining its signature combat, the game masterfully blended elements from its predecessors and 'Bloodborne,' showcasing the studio's complete command over its innovative gameplay loop. Despite widespread critical praise, 'Dark Souls 3' was nominated only for Best RPG in 2016, a year stacked with strong contenders like 'Overwatch,' 'Doom,' and 'Inside.' The article notes that particularly challenging games can face an uphill battle in GOTY races.
Outer Wilds
A unique blend of open-world exploration, action-adventure, and puzzle mechanics, 'Outer Wilds' eschewed traditional combat in favor of rewarding player curiosity. Its immersive, combat-free experience was underpinned by a tightly woven narrative. In 2019, it faced exceptionally stiff competition from titles such as 'Control,' 'Death Stranding,' and 'Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice.' As an indie title that gained traction through word-of-mouth, 'Outer Wilds' was a deserving but ultimately unlikely GOTY nominee.
NieR: Automata
This spin-off from the 'Drakengard' series brought 'NieR: Automata' to mainstream audiences with its intricate, existential narrative and seamless shifts between bullet-hell, hack-and-slash, and side-scrolling gameplay. While a critical and commercial success, it competed against mainstream giants like 'Breath of the Wild' and 'Super Mario Odyssey.' The game's philosophical depth and multiple endings may have proven too complex for some voters.
Ghost of Yotei
The successor to 'Ghost of Tsushima,' 'Ghost of Yotei,' aimed for cinematic grandeur, drawing inspiration from filmmakers like Takashi Miike and Shinichiro Watanabe. It garnered multiple nominations in 2025, including Best Direction and Best Action/Adventure Game. However, it was notably absent from the GOTY category, with critics suggesting it did not sufficiently distinguish itself from its predecessor, a phenomenon sometimes referred to as a "sequel tax."
Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze
Praised as a masterclass in platformer design, 'Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze' featured meticulously crafted levels and purposeful gimmicks, complemented by a memorable soundtrack from David Wise. Released in 2014, the inaugural year of The Game Awards, it competed in a landscape that favored different types of games. Its initial release on the Wii U, a commercially less successful console, also impacted its reach.
Hollow Knight
Considered one of the best games of the 2010s, 'Hollow Knight' offered players a vast, mysterious world with minimal direction. Its slow-burn popularity, typical of many indie titles, meant it lacked the blockbuster momentum to secure a GOTY nomination in 2017. Its sequel, 'Hollow Knight: Silksong,' later received an indirect nod through its own nomination.
Silent Hill 2
The remake of the psychological horror classic 'Silent Hill 2' updated its gameplay to modern standards while preserving the original's oppressive atmosphere and emotional weight. However, horror games often struggle to gain traction at The Game Awards, and remakes are historically rare GOTY nominees. Only one horror-adjacent game, 'The Last of Us Part II,' has won the award.
Fire Emblem: Three Houses
'Fire Emblem: Three Houses' became the best-selling entry in its series, captivating players with its branching narrative and complex themes of war and betrayal. Despite its success, it faced a highly competitive 2019 lineup and some technical drawbacks, including its graphics and repetitive hub world. The need to play through multiple story routes to grasp the full narrative may have also hindered its broad appeal.
Yakuza 0
'Yakuza 0' was lauded for its dual protagonists, compelling crime drama, over-the-top combat, and quirky humor, all while maintaining the series' distinct "cool factor." Released internationally in 2016, its initial limited reach in Western markets was partly attributed to the absence of an English dub, a factor that slowed its viral spread. The game's subsequent release on PC and a Director's Cut with a dub significantly boosted its popularity and sales.
Mina the Hollower
'Mina the Hollower' is highlighted as a particularly baffling GOTY snub this year. Its intricate level design, a loving homage to early Zelda titles, the Game Boy Color, and Gothic horror, rivaled AAA productions in its quality. While nominated for Best Indie Game, it was notably absent from the GOTY list, which focused heavily on mainstream blockbusters. The game's challenging difficulty may have also limited its mass appeal among The Game Awards voters.