As anticipation for Grand Theft Auto 6 builds, the question of which installment in the storied franchise reigns supreme becomes a topic of passionate debate. Eurogamer's "The Big Question" series tackles this very point, with staff members championing their personal favorites: Grand Theft Auto: Vice City, Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas, and Grand Theft Auto 4.
For Dom, Grand Theft Auto: Vice City remains the pinnacle of the series. He highlights its immaculate '80s Miami setting, capturing a sun-drenched, cocaine-fueled excess that perfectly complements the game's themes of freedom and fantasy. The initial half of the game introduces players to Tommy Vercetti's rise within a world of narcotic hedonism, before opening up into a second half focused on building an empire through businesses and street-level power. Dom argues that Vice City maintained focus, unlike San Andreas which he feels strayed too far, and that Rockstar's ambitious, star-studded cast and development energy at the time created a game bursting at its seams, a sentiment he believes GTA 6 might echo.
Bertie's choice is Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas, a game that left the biggest impression due to its attempt to portray Black culture. Through the character of CJ, the game offered a vicarious experience of West Coast rap and hip-hop life, akin to an NWA origin story. Bertie acknowledges the potential for stereotypes but emphasizes the appeal of this