While not as beloved as its Christmas or Halloween counterparts, A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving holds a unique place in the Peanuts canon, largely due to the inclusion of Franklin Armstrong. Polygon argues that despite the special's narrative and animation shortcomings, Franklin's presence is a significant symbolic act. The special, which aired in 1973, came just a few years after the introduction of Franklin to the comic strip in 1968, a decision spurred by a letter from Harriet Glickman following the assassination of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Glickman urged creator Charles Schulz to add a Black character to promote racial equality, a move Schulz initially hesitated about due to fears of appearing patronizing.

Schulz's correspondence with Glickman led to Franklin's debut in the comic strip on July 31, 1968. This introduction was met with significant backlash from racist readers, but Schulz staunchly defended the character, famously stating to his syndicator, "Either you print it just the way I draw it or I quit." This stance highlighted Schulz's commitment to the character's inclusion, using his considerable platform to make a statement during a turbulent period in American history.

Within the Thanksgiving special itself, Franklin's role is limited, but his inclusion is seen as a continuation of Schulz's principled stand. The special has faced modern criticism for a scene where Franklin sits alone on one side of the table in a lawn chair, which some interpret as segregationist. However, Polygon suggests this might be an oversight by Schulz and director Bill Melendez, or simply a way to develop the character, especially as the lawn chair collapses later in the scene. Another moment, a unique handshake between Charlie Brown and Franklin, is also seen as an early attempt to give the character a distinct personality.

A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving Peanuts Franklin

The article posits that given Schulz's earlier defense of Franklin, it's unlikely he would have deliberately undermined his own efforts. Ultimately, the author identifies Peppermint Patty's line, "No, you can come as you are, Franklin," after Franklin asks if he should wear a tie, as the special's most poignant quote. This exchange, along with Franklin's deliberate inclusion in an intimate gathering of chosen friends, underscores the special's importance as a moment of symbolic equality, despite its narrative weaknesses.