The announcement of The Game Awards nominees has once again ignited discussions about the year's best games, and inevitably, the notable omissions. For one writer, the perceived snubbing of two particular 2D titles, Mina the Hollower and Castlevania: Belmont's Curse, highlighted a broader trend of 2D games being overlooked in favor of their 3D counterparts.

Mina the Hollower, described as a blend of classic Zelda sensibilities with Elder Scrolls scope, received only one nomination for Best Independent Game. Castlevania: Belmont's Curse, a modern metroidvania praised for its action-game combat, was not nominated at all. While Castlevania's lack of nominations might be understandable given a more niche reception, Mina the Hollower's omission is more puzzling, especially considering its high aggregated score on Metacritic, which reportedly surpasses many nominees in the Best Action Game and Best Action/Adventure categories.

Several factors may contribute to this oversight. Recency bias, where games released closer to the nomination deadline are favored, could play a role, though several 3D games released earlier than Mina the Hollower did receive nominations. More fundamentally, the author suggests that a lingering perception of 2D games as retro throwbacks, rather than vehicles for true innovation and impeccable design, might be at play. The Game Awards, in particular, are seen as celebrating big-budget productions and impressive visuals, often overshadowing the more subtle achievements of 2D titles.

Despite this, the article acknowledges that 2D games are not entirely ignored, citing past nominations for titles like Hollow Knight: Silksong and Super Mario Bros. Wonder for Game of the Year. However, it argues that the focus on spectacle at The Game Awards can be frustrating when it leads to overlooking more nuanced successes like Mina the Hollower, a game developed by a studio that has spent years perfecting its craft and deserves greater recognition regardless of its dimensionality.