The controversial mob tagging system, where only the first player to damage a creature receives credit for its defeat, is a point of contention in old-school MMOs, according to PC Gamer's "Terminally Online" column. Harvey, the column's author, acknowledges the divisive nature of the mechanic, particularly in the context of World of Warcraft: Forever.

Harvey argues that mob tagging can serve as a necessary tool to encourage social interaction in MMOs. The shared challenge of defeating mobs can incentivize players to group up, leading to more collaborative gameplay and even opportunities for conversation with strangers. This, he suggests, can foster a more social environment than would otherwise exist, leading to new friendships and interactions within the game. He notes that this system has led to him forming new connections that he might have otherwise missed.

However, the column also recognizes the frustrations associated with mob tagging. Especially in newly launched, popular games like WoW: Forever, where player density can be high, the system can become a significant impediment. Harvey describes situations where the mechanic shifts from encouraging banter to creating annoyance, particularly with "loot X" quests where grouping offers no benefit. The author points out that the system's effectiveness diminishes when large numbers of players are present and quest objectives do not benefit from cooperation.

This critique raises a question for the gaming community: Is mob tagging a valuable, albeit sometimes inconvenient, feature that contributes to the classic MMO experience, or is it an outdated mechanic that should be removed in favor of more modern systems? The "Terminally Online" column invites readers to share their perspectives on this ongoing debate in the comments section.