David Tennant's tenure as the Doctor on Doctor Who is often remembered for his character's compassion and unwavering moral compass. However, the 2009 special "The Waters of Mars" presented a starkly different side of the Time Lord, exploring themes of power, hubris, and the immense burden of his unique existence. The episode showcased a Doctor pushed to his emotional limit, a stark departure from the pacifist ideals typically espoused by the character.
The Time Lord Victorious
The core tenet of the Doctor's philosophy, established early in the show's history, is a commitment to peace and kindness. This is exemplified by the Twelfth Doctor's dying words: "never be cruel, never be cowardly, and never ever eat pears! Remember, hate is always foolish, but love is always wise. Always try to be nice, but never fail to be kind." "The Waters of Mars" directly challenges this by depicting the Tenth Doctor exhibiting a profound lack of these qualities.
The narrative unfolds on Mars in 2059 at Bowie Base One, humanity's first off-world colony, led by Captain Adelaide Brooke. The Doctor arrives to discover that the entire colony is fated to perish in a cataclysm – a fixed point in time. This realization is compounded by the presence of the Flood, an intelligent, waterborne alien virus that infects humans and turns them into relentless, zombie-like creatures. Despite the dire circumstances, the Doctor finds himself in an impossible ethical dilemma.
He had previously intervened in a fixed point in time, saving a family in "The Fires of Pompeii" alongside his companion Donna Noble. Now, faced with a similar situation, the Doctor wrestles with the potential ramifications of saving Adelaide Brooke. Saving her would mean her granddaughter, Susie, would not be inspired to become the first human captain to pilot a lightspeed ship to Proxima Centauri, a pivotal event in human history.
Traveling alone and still reeling from the loss of Donna, the Doctor becomes consumed by frustration. The constant cycle of saving lives only to lose companions and face further despair drives him to a breaking point. He yearns for a decisive victory, a moment where he can assert control over the relentless march of time.
This emotional turmoil culminates in a moment of immense hubris. The Doctor declares, "There are laws of time. Once upon a time there were people in charge of those laws, but they died. They all died. Do you know who that leaves? Me! It's taken me all these years to realize that the laws of time are mine and they will obey me!" This proclamation echoes the villainous pronouncements of his rival, The Master, highlighting the dangerous line the Doctor treads.
In a show of what he perceives as mastery over time, the Doctor intervenes and saves Adelaide. However, his victory is short-lived. Back on Earth, Adelaide, horrified by the Doctor's god-like pronouncements and the implications of his power, takes her own life to preserve the timeline. This tragic event underscores the profound consequences of the Doctor's actions and the immutable nature of fixed points in time.
The episode serves as a potent reminder that the Doctor's arrogance, while often a source of strength, can also be his greatest weakness. Without the grounding influence of his companions, he is susceptible to succumbing to the very darkness he fights against, demonstrating that even the greatest heroes can be their own worst monsters.