Director James Gray returns to his crime drama roots with Paper Tiger, a film that features some of the strongest performances of Adam Driver, Miles Teller, and Scarlett Johansson's careers. Set in Queens, New York, in 1986, the movie centers on two brothers, the family-oriented engineer Irwin Pearl (Teller) and his charismatic, former-cop brother Gary (Driver). Gary proposes a business venture where they would offer consulting services to a Russian immigrant-run clean-up firm working on the polluted Gowanus Canal, utilizing Gary's City Hall connections and Irwin's engineering expertise.
What begins as a seemingly mutually beneficial opportunity to ease financial burdens—Gary dealing with a costly divorce, Irwin facing looming college tuition for his son—quickly unravels when Irwin discovers the Russians are a mob front. The danger escalates when Irwin, his wife Hester (Johansson), and their two teenage sons become targets.
The film portrays the Pearl family as ordinary, working-class individuals ill-equipped for the perilous world they stumble into. Gary, the ambitious and slick brother, is depicted not as inherently bad but as someone with a surprising moral compass, even as his actions draw his family into danger. Adam Driver's performance captures the complexities of a man whose outward bluster hides vulnerabilities, suggesting a deep affection for his brother and family.
Miles Teller is noted as a revelation as Irwin, a man out of his depth who must find courage in a terrifying situation. His portrayal is a departure from his earlier, more bravado-filled roles, drawing comparisons to characters played by Dustin Hoffman. Scarlett Johansson delivers one of her best performances as Hester, a seemingly conventional housewife whose authentic and heartbreaking reactions to shocking news are a highlight.
The palpable fear experienced by the Pearl family is amplified by their ordinary lives, making the peril they face all the more unsettling. A home invasion sequence is particularly effective, relying on unnerving sound design over explicit visuals. Cinematographer Joaquin Baca-Asay's work, shot on 35mm film, lends the movie a gritty, authentic period feel reminiscent of 1970s or 80s cinema, complemented by the lived-in production and costume design. The film's verdict highlights it as an engaging, character-driven thriller where family ambitions, secrets, and a lack of truth portend tragedy.
