The third season of The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power delves into the origin of Sauron's Nine Nazgûl, or Ringwraiths, presenting their transformation not as an immediate enslavement but as a gradual process fueled by the deceptive gifts of the Rings of Power. Co-creator Patrick McKay stated that a key goal for the series is to dramatize the allure of these rings, explaining that they initially offer healing, power, and wealth before ultimately demanding the wearers' freedom.
Executive producer Charlotte Brändström aimed to make the Nazgûl both human and unsettling. This is achieved through stylistic choices such as filming their movements and voices at slower frame rates and incorporating echoes and reverberation. Brändström noted that their unnerving composure, stemming from an awareness of their power, contributes to their frightening presence. Crucially, the show emphasizes that at this stage, the Nazgûl have not yet fully lost their humanity, a contrast to the completely corrupted beings of later ages.
Sauron's method of creating these Nazgûl is depicted through brutal trials. In the early episodes of season 3, three kings of men are already serving as Nazgûl. The process is shown when five leaders from Rhûn arrive in Mordor. After a contest ensues, Sauron bestows a Ring of Power upon Khamûl the Easterling, who undergoes a painful transformation that eradicates a curse and grants him immense power. This portrayal aligns with Tolkien's lore, where Khamûl is a significant figure, though his recruitment circumstances are specific to the series.
Another character undergoing this transformation is Theo. Following a similar violent ritual where he proves himself worthy, Sauron manipulates Theo's desperation and resentment. Sauron claims Theo descends from a lineage sworn to Mordor, justifying the bestowal of a ring. Actor Tyroe Muhafidin, who plays Theo, described his character's initial state as one of anger and pain, which Sauron exploits. By the time Theo begins to grasp the potential cost of the ring, it is already too late.
The lingering humanity of the Nazgûl is further explored during a climactic battle. Theo, now a Nazgûl, confronts Arondir. Unlike the fully consumed wraiths of the Third Age, Theo still possesses autonomy and urges Arondir to flee. However, Sauron intervenes, forcing Theo to kill Arondir, demonstrating that despite their remaining humanity, Sauron's control is becoming absolute. The series thus questions whether the Nazgûl are more or less frightening when their former human selves are still visible beneath the encroaching darkness.