The third season of The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power has already seen significant character deaths, with showrunners Patrick McKay and J.D. Payne explaining their deliberate choice to underscore the escalating threat of Sauron and the high stakes of the narrative. "There are real stakes," McKay told IGN. "There is a real cost to what Sauron is doing. As we were in the writers’ room, myself and J.D., very early on, we felt that the audience needed to feel that and feel it viscerally. We had to take things from the audience. It had to hurt."

Eärien's Calculated Exit

Ema Horvath's character, Eärien, Elendil's daughter, dies by suicide in Episode 2 rather than face punishment from King Pharazôn. Eärien had been acting as a mole for the exiled queen regent Míriel, feeding information to her brother Isildur for five years. McKay noted that Eärien's story was designed to mirror the shock of Marion Crane's death in Alfred Hitchcock's Psycho, aiming to disrupt the audience by removing a central character early on.

Horvath stated that she knew Eärien's arc would be contained within Númenor from the outset but was unaware of the specifics of her exit until pitched by the showrunners. "They're very good at animating the world for you," she recalled of the Zoom call where she received the news. "So they got to the end of what happened and I was so into the story that I got off the Zoom and my husband was like, ‘Did you hear what they said? Did you not process it, because you're not behaving like the way someone would react to that information?’"

Reflecting on her character's motivations, Horvath described Eärien as someone battling "shame" for her actions, hoping that a second viewing would reveal the deep sadness beneath the surface. The actress also mentioned that the birth of her first child between seasons deepened her performance. The scene of Eärien's death, where she walks out a window to her demise, was intentionally shot with a wide lens to emphasize her agency and the finality of her choice, according to director Charlotte Brändström.

The Tragic Demise of Arondir

The season's second major death occurs in "Gundabad" with the demise of the Elven warrior Arondir, portrayed by Ismael Cruz Córdova. His death comes during a confrontation with Theo, his human lover's son, who has been conscripted into Sauron's forces. McKay explained that the tragic intersection of Theo and Arondir's paths was a foundational idea for the season's narrative.

Córdova shared that Arondir's "dark night of the soul" journey resonated with his own personal experiences, particularly during filming Season 2 and into Season 3 while dealing with a parent's illness. He noted the poignant timing of being told about Arondir's fate on the same day his father received a diagnosis. The actor also revealed that a personal tragedy occurred the day before shooting Arondir's death sequence.

Before his character's end, Córdova expressed gratitude for the opportunity to explore Arondir's softer side through his relationships with Galadriel and the Orc Marnûkh, allowing him to showcase a wider range of the character's complexity. He also discussed his character's consistent attire as a deliberate choice, symbolizing Arondir's unwavering identity amidst the unfolding events. The final moments of Arondir's life were particularly difficult for actor Tyroe Muhafidin (Theo), who struggled with the act of killing his character. Córdova emphasized his care for Muhafidin, wanting him to know that the actions were not his fault and that Arondir and he believed in him.

McKay commended both Horvath and Córdova for their understanding and commitment to their characters' arcs, calling their deaths "the correct, if painful, end of their journeys."