Steven Spielberg's 1982 horror film Poltergeist, often cited as his scariest movie, is now available to stream for free on Pluto TV. The film, which follows a suburban family terrorized by supernatural forces and the abduction of their youngest daughter by entities from another dimension, continues to be a subject of debate regarding its directorial credit.
The Directional Dispute
While Tobe Hooper is officially credited as the director, his work on The Texas Chainsaw Massacre and other intense horror films predated Poltergeist. Steven Spielberg, who produced the film, has been the subject of ongoing speculation that he, not Hooper, was the true director. The origins of the film are muddled, with some accounts suggesting it evolved from Spielberg's earlier sci-fi horror concept, Night Skies, which he later reworked into E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial. Hooper, however, maintained he conceived of Poltergeist independently.
During production, Spielberg was reportedly very hands-on, leading to a perception of two directors on set. Camera assistant John Leonetti claimed Spielberg effectively directed the film, while stars JoBeth Williams and Craig T. Nelson acknowledged Spielberg's significant producer role but maintained Hooper was the director. Actress Zelda Rubinstein described it as a collaborative effort with Spielberg having a slight edge in control.
Contemporary interviews from 1982, including one with Spielberg himself, have added to the confusion. Spielberg described Hooper as "not a take-charge sort of guy" and admitted to jumping in with directorial decisions. The Directors Guild reportedly investigated the matter due to MGM and United Artists promoting Spielberg's name over Hooper's, leading to a fine for the studio to compensate Hooper.
A Collaborative Masterpiece?
Style also plays a role in the debate. Some point to the film's polished suburban setting and family focus as indicative of Spielberg's touch, contrasting with Hooper's typically grittier style. However, the film's more gruesome moments, such as a paranormal investigator peeling off his face or a character falling into a pit of bodies, align with Hooper's established horror sensibilities. The considerable budget available for Poltergeist may have also allowed for a higher production value than Hooper typically worked with.
Ultimately, the film's blend of accessible family drama and genuine terror suggests a true collaboration. Both Spielberg and Hooper were masters of building tension, a skill evident in their respective works like Spielberg's Jaws and Hooper's The Texas Chainsaw Massacre. Had they been credited as co-directors, the controversy might have been avoided. Nevertheless, Poltergeist remains a significant horror film from the 1980s, appealing to fans of both directors.