Polygon has ranked all 22 campaigns from the Call of Duty series. The list includes titles from the Modern Warfare and Black Ops sub-series, as well as standalone entries like Advanced Warfare and WWII.
The Bottom of the Barrel
At the lowest end of the ranking is 2025's Call of Duty: Black Ops 7. Polygon criticizes its nonsensical narrative, flat open-world missions, and reliance on hallucinogenic substances, citing boss fights against fantastical creatures and a lack of engagement when playing solo. Following closely is Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3 (2023), which is faulted for its introduction of aimless "open combat missions" and a departure from the series' traditional squad-based gameplay, leading to a lonely experience despite technical advancements.
Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 also lands low on the list, characterized as a miss in the futuristic Call of Duty entries. Its campaign is noted for focusing on robots and augmented soldiers, with abilities and skill tree upgrades deemed unnecessary for a linear experience. The original Call of Duty from 2003, while foundational, is ranked lower due to its dated mechanics compared to modern titles. Similarly, Call of Duty: Ghosts is considered an underwhelming entry that began a period of mediocre sequels, despite a standout character in Riley the dog. Call of Duty: Infinite Warfare is placed lower due to its structure, which included a hub world and player choice in mission order, and a perceived weak cast performance. Call of Duty 2 is acknowledged as holding up better than its predecessor but doesn't introduce significant innovations by today's standards.
Mid-Tier Entries
Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare is seen as a precursor to Infinite Warfare, marking the beginning of the controversial "jetpack era" and featuring a notable performance from Kevin Spacey. Call of Duty 3, the first developed by Treyarch, is recognized for introducing diverse gameplay approaches and improving tank mechanics, alongside the now-staple ability to throw grenades back.
Call of Duty: Black Ops 2 is praised for its tight mechanics and interesting "Strike Force" missions that influenced the game's outcome and ending. However, its convoluted timeline jumps between past and future and poorly designed Strike Force missions detract from its overall quality.