House House, the studio behind the celebrated multiplayer game Big Walk, recently found itself at the center of a debate regarding its use of AI tools to overcome a significant technical hurdle. The development team resorted to a large language model (LLM) chatbot to solve a lighting physics issue within Unity, the game engine they utilized.
This decision led to a statement from influential members of the Indie Game Festival jury, declaring they would not vote for any game employing generative AI tools, which includes Big Walk. The situation has ignited discussions about the ethics of AI in game development, the necessity of disclosure for AI usage, and how players should approach games that incorporate such technology.
Jake Strasser, co-founder of House House and a lead designer on Big Walk, discussed the game's development prior to the controversy, focusing on how proximity chat shaped the experience and the importance of collaboration. Despite the technical assistance from an LLM, Strasser emphasized the extensive human effort invested by the five-person team.
Big Walk originated as a way for the developers to connect during COVID-19 lockdowns. Initially conceived as a smaller project to explore networking for a larger endeavor, its focus shifted when the team discovered the profound potential of shared virtual spaces facilitated by proximity voice chat. The game evolved into a platform designed to foster a truly shared multiplayer experience, a stark contrast to games where players might operate in parallel.
During its development, the team experimented with various challenges, including a constructed cinema screen for playing music, which Strasser described as one of the first sparks of magic. Early challenge designs, like a gauntlet requiring one player to navigate while others operated doors, were found to be less engaging if they allowed for solo progression. The game’s design deliberately incorporates elements that necessitate cooperation, such as requiring two players to deposit collected items.
Strasser also touched on the game's grounded physics and recognizable elements, drawing parallels to Untitled Goose Game. This approach, he explained, allows players to intuitively understand the game's rules by grounding them in real-world physics and social dynamics, making it easier to engage with the experience.
The narrative aspect of Big Walk is not explicitly defined by the developers, with Strasser suggesting the game's true story is the playthroughs and connections players forge. The team has received numerous accounts from players reconnecting with family members, strengthening sibling bonds, and finding new ways to communicate with loved ones through the game.
He described the game's ending as a microcosm of the entire experience: players are stripped of their voices and anonymized, forcing them to rely on the communication skills developed throughout the game. This challenge, Strasser noted, is a deliberate push to have players rely on each other and their learned abilities to succeed, culminating in a powerful moment when they regain their voices.
Despite its unconventional development and the recent AI-related controversy, Strasser believes Big Walk is a remarkable creative achievement that has deeply resonated with its players, fulfilling the team's vision for a truly impactful shared experience.