The critically acclaimed game Big Walk finds itself at a pivotal moment as awards season approaches, following the developer's disclosure of using generative AI tools. This revelation has prompted a segment of the Independent Game Festival (IGF) jury to announce a boycott of any game that incorporates AI in its development, creating a complex situation for Big Walk's Game of the Year (GOTY) aspirations.
On November 10, 2026, 19 IGF jurors, including notable figures like Sam Barlow and Austin Walker, published a statement declaring their refusal to vote for any game that employed generative AI tools. Barlow indicated that the discussion surrounding AI in game development was particularly intense this year, with Big Walk's use of such technology serving as a focal point.
House House, the developer behind Big Walk, disclosed in a statement that generative AI tools were used for a minimal portion of the game's code, specifically less than 0.1%. These tools were primarily employed to assist with challenging technical issues and bugs. As an example, the studio cited the use of large language models (LLMs) to help resolve a lighting problem, which amounted to approximately 10 lines of code.
The jurors who issued the statement cited concerns regarding the broader negative impacts of AI on the economy, labor market, environment, and information integrity. They emphasized that the industry has not yet settled on a consensus regarding AI's role and that this stance provides an opportunity for independent developers to voice their position.
A significant aspect of this jury's position is the inclusion of AI-generated code within their boycott, a distinction often not made in public discourse which tends to focus on creative assets like art and writing. This broadens the scope of the debate and has been met with appreciation from programmers who view coding as an artistic endeavor.
The controversy has generated varied reactions within the gaming community. Some argue that House House's failure to disclose AI use upon the game's release is a point of contention, questioning what else might have been omitted from disclosure. Others view the AI usage as minimal and argue that strict delineations could disqualify many games. The studio's past philanthropic efforts, such as donating a portion of profits from Untitled Goose Game, are also noted by some as indicators of goodwill.
The impact of this controversy on Big Walk's GOTY chances remains uncertain. While the statement originated from a limited number of jurors, its public visibility could influence other voters. The situation is particularly relevant for The Game Awards, where Big Walk was considered a strong contender for a nomination. However, the history of AI controversies affecting awards is not unprecedented; Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 had its Indie Game Award for GOTY rescinded in 2025 due to AI inclusion.
This incident highlights the ongoing struggle within the game industry to navigate the integration of generative AI. While some developers and studios have taken firm stances against AI use, others, like Embark Studios and Epic Games, have been more open to its implementation. House House has acknowledged the situation, stating, "Big Walk was developed without an internal AI usage policy in place, and we consider that lack of policy a failure. We will work to have a more comprehensive policy going forwards."
This statement suggests a commitment to establishing clearer guidelines for AI in future projects. However, the article notes that the responsibility for developing such policies should not fall solely on individual developers, advocating for broader industry and governmental regulations to address the complexities of AI usage.