The recent free update for The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+, which launched on consoles alongside Grand Theft Auto 6, has become a point of contention for players due to the inclusion of AI-generated music. The update, which arrived on PC earlier in 2024 and on PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X/S, and Switch this week, introduced a special "Vice City mode" accessible via a specific game seed.

Players who entered the seed "V1CE BSMT" could engage in a Grand Theft Auto-inspired run featuring unique weapons and music. However, a Reddit user later posted a detailed breakdown alleging that the music tracks were created using Suno, an AI-based music generation tool. Evidence cited includes metadata found within some of the audio files, such as comment: made with suno; created=2026-10-30T17:53:41Z; id=cd5a5b55-bead-4cb9-949d-09ed1f917dce.

The discovery led to significant player frustration, with many criticizing the use of AI and the perceived corner-cutting by the development team, particularly Nicalis, the publisher and co-developer. Complaints about existing bugs and quality control issues within the expansion have reportedly been accumulating. The AI music incident has resulted in a review-bombing of the expansion's Steam page, which currently shows a user rating of only 9 percent positive.

Edmund McMillen, the creator of The Binding of Isaac, expressed surprise at the situation, stating on X that he was unaware of the AI-generated music. "Woke up to a shit show, obviously I had no idea it featured generated music in the daily run, looking into how that happened and getting it removed, stay tuned," he posted.

An emergency update has since been released to remove the AI-generated music and address other issues. However, Nicalis has not yet issued a statement taking responsibility for the use of AI or explaining its inclusion. The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ also did not include the required Steam store page disclosures for AI-generated content. McMillen had previously commented to Eurogamer that the Grand Theft Auto 6 stunt was Nicalis's idea, intended as a "funny experiment" to coincide with the release of the highly anticipated title.