Players attempting to create Horde characters on North American PvP realms in World of Warcraft: Forever are currently facing a block, with a message indicating that the faction is unavailable due to population imbalance. This restriction extends to both regular PvP and RP PvP realms, as confirmed by testing.
This situation arises from a significant imbalance in faction populations on PvP servers. In North America, the Horde significantly outnumbers the Alliance, making it impossible to create new Horde characters on these realms. Conversely, European RP-PvP realms are experiencing a similar issue in reverse, with an excess of Alliance players.
Players of the less dominant factions have voiced concerns in community forums, describing the imbalance as making the game nearly unplayable. They report being consistently outnumbered and frequently killed while questing, with the issue exacerbated by low experience gains from dungeons and the constant threat of PvP engagement. Unlike in the retail version of World of Warcraft, Forever lacks "Sanctuaries" where PvP is disabled, meaning players are vulnerable in most areas outside of their starting zones, which are only protected by high-level NPCs.
Some players have also speculated that the game's new "layering" system may be contributing to the problem, sometimes placing players in zones with a disproportionate number of opposing faction members. There have also been theories about free trial accounts being used to artificially inflate the Horde population. However, Blizzard has stated that the trial account issue is not impacting the imbalance.
In response, Blizzard has announced adjustments to character creation to temporarily block the creation of new characters on the overpopulated faction side. The developer confirmed that the faction balance has reached a "most extreme" split of 55/45 in some cases, which, while seemingly small, is "not as close as we want it to be" and is causing player issues. Blizzard is also implementing broader adjustments to the layering system, with specific enhancements for PvP servers, to help alleviate these population disparities.
These measures are intended to improve the PvP experience in the coming days and weeks. Players who prefer to avoid such imbalances have the option to play on normal realms, where they can choose their faction and opt into PvP when desired, without the constant threat of open-world conflict.