The first expansion for the arcane science-fantasy roguelike Caves of Qud, titled Diaspora, is set to introduce a host of new playable species, including animals and plants. This expansion aims to expand the game's already complex body plan-agnostic mutation system, but has presented its developers, Freehold Games, with a unique set of design and philosophical challenges. Discussions have ranged from the existential tragedy of a sinning tree to the practicalities of a crab attempting to get high.

Co-creators Brian Bucklew and Jason Grinblat spoke with PC Gamer about the implications of these new species. "We have text on this in-game," Grinblat said, referencing an in-game book that touches on the fate of creatures transformed against their nature. He mused that becoming a tree might be preferable to being a man, while Bucklew noted the real-world parallels to transformations and the question of identity.

Diaspora's new plant and animal gene-stocks will feature different body plans. A crab character, for instance, will have six legs and potentially a claw, while a bear might be a quadruped without traditional hands. These distinct anatomies will grant species-specific mutation bonuses, allowing inherent traits like wings or tails to advance faster and unlock unique abilities. "We want every animal to have something weird and unique about them that you can't just get if you were a human and you advance that mutation a bunch," Grinblat explained.

However, these specialized forms come with inherent limitations. A mutant dog character, for example, will not be able to wield a gun without acquiring new hands or mutating a prehensile tail. "This is a big thing. No," Grinblat stated. "Right now, no. You're a dog." While players can find artifacts like the "helping hands" item or develop a prehensile tail, the developers intend to encourage playstyles that lean into the natural strengths of animal forms rather than simply replicating human capabilities.

The expansion has also led to complex discussions about the game's core systems and questlines, which were originally designed with a human-shaped player in mind. "The limbs have taken the bulk of it, but there are other issues," Grinblat noted. He cited examples like a crab being unable to tattoo themselves for a quest, or a plant character being unable to eat certain items required for progression. "How does a crab get high? Like, it's an integral part of a Caves of Qud quest, and a crab is not very good at it," Bucklew said, highlighting the difficulty of adapting existing content.

After considerable deliberation, the developers concluded that crabs could likely hold a tattoo gun in their claws. The question of how plants might tattoo themselves remains for another day. Caves of Qud: Diaspora is scheduled to launch in early access on Steam on December 9.