James Gunn and Peter Safran have stepped down as co-CEOs of DC Studios, with MCU veteran Jeremy Latcham reportedly set to take their place. This marks the latest upheaval for a division that has experienced significant turmoil in recent years. Despite the change in leadership, there is a strong imperative for the DC Universe (DCU) to continue its established trajectory.

Years of Corporate Instability

Warner Bros. has long struggled to build a cohesive competitor to Disney's Marvel Cinematic Universe. While solo Batman films have found success, establishing a shared universe has proven difficult. The critical and commercial underperformance of 2016's Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice was a significant setback for the DC Extended Universe (DCEU), with subsequent corporate shake-ups hindering any sustained momentum. The studio's past decisions, such as shelving the Batgirl movie for tax write-offs and wavering on which Batman actor should lead the franchise, underscore a lack of clear direction.

This instability continued until Gunn and Safran took charge in 2023, unveiling their "Chapter 1: Gods and Monsters" plan. This initiative aimed to create an interconnected slate of films and TV shows designed to unify the DC brand. The new DCU commenced with the release of Superman in 2025, followed by Supergirl, Lanterns, and Clayface this year. However, the DCU's journey has not been without its challenges. While Superman performed adequately, Supergirl has been identified as a significant box-office disappointment for 2026, and Clayface's success is attributed to its lower budget. The performance of Supergirl is speculated to have influenced Skydance's decision regarding Gunn and Safran's tenure.

Critics have also pointed to a perceived lack of focus on DC's most prominent characters, questioning the prioritization of figures like Peacemaker and Clayface over established heroes like Batman and Wonder Woman. This has led to speculation that Skydance may favor a more traditional approach to the DC brand, shifting away from Gunn's more unconventional creative choices. While upcoming projects like Mister Miracle and The People v. Gorilla Grodd have generated anticipation, a strategic focus on core franchises is seen by some as a more pragmatic direction for the studio.

The Case for Continuity

The primary concern following Gunn and Safran's departure is that Skydance might opt for a complete reboot of the DCU. After years of corporate instability and shifting creative visions, another reboot would be a disservice to the brand and its audience, especially after the recent transition from the DCEU to the DCU.

Abandoning the current DCU would signal a lack of confidence from Skydance and could alienate moviegoers. The studio is urged to maintain the established continuity and retain key actors such as David Corenswet as Superman, Aaron Pierre as Green Lantern, and Milly Alcock as Supergirl. A prolonged search for new actors to portray these iconic roles would be a detrimental setback.

Furthermore, shelving projects already in development, such as Man of Tomorrow (currently in post-production) and The People v. Gorilla Grodd (reportedly well into filming), would be a costly and wasteful mistake. Such actions would mirror the shelving of the Batgirl movie and subject audiences to yet another Superman reboot.

The DC brand requires a clear and consistent vision. While the execution of the DCU has faced criticism, the foundational principles of Gunn and Safran's plan—establishing a shared universe with a deep history that allows creative freedom—are considered sound. The DCU's approach, often compared to Star Wars rather than the MCU, is crucial for its unique identity.

Even with new leadership, this fundamental approach should persist. A viable path forward for Skydance involves preserving the DCU's continuity and tone while strategically focusing on its most marketable properties. There remains potential for Gunn to continue contributing to DC projects, perhaps focusing on writing and directing, allowing him to concentrate on filmmaking while others manage corporate responsibilities. Gunn has indicated he is working on a "secret" script for the studio, and his involvement in rebooting Batman for the DCU has been suggested.

While Gunn and Safran's tenure did not entirely cure all of DC's cinematic issues, it marked significant progress. Skydance is advised not to discard the progress made and instead build upon the successes of the DCU, avoiding another costly reboot.