Embark Studios has apologized and removed a recap video from The Finals' APAC Closed Qualifiers after widespread criticism for replacing the tournament's human esports casters with AI voices. The video featured audio from the game's in-game AI commentators, Scotty and June, who even repeated lines from the original casters.

The decision drew sharp criticism from esports personalities. ProtoANZ, a caster for The Finals, expressed disappointment on X, stating that after significant effort, they were "replaced by two AI casters who even quote us." Bluepanda, another caster, shared a similar sentiment, highlighting a perceived lack of value for their work over nearly seven years.

Other esports figures also voiced their support. Sam "Initialise" Hapgood called the situation "dystopian," and Jen "LemonKiwi" Pichette described it as "appalling."

Embark's use of AI has been a point of discussion previously. The studio had announced a "dynamic commentary" feature for The Finals and defended its use of AI voices in Arc Raiders, citing impracticality in recording all possible dialogue with human actors.

In response to the backlash, Oscar Lundberg, Embark's community and competitive operations lead, issued an apology on X. He stated that replacing the casters' voices with AI "wasn't the right call" and that the intention was to generate casual interest in The Finals esports. Lundberg confirmed the video had been removed and would not be re-released in its current form, with planned recaps for other regions also being reconsidered.

Despite the apology, some casters felt it was insufficient, suggesting the studio only relented due to public outcry. ProtoANZ called for the formation of an esports talent union to advocate for contractual protections against the use of voices in generative AI.