Embark Studios is under fire from the esports community following the use of AI commentators in highlight reels for The Finals' Grand Major tournament. A now-deleted video showcasing highlights from the APAC Closed Qualifiers featured the game's fictional AI casters, Scotty and June, instead of the human commentators who covered the event.
Several prominent casters voiced their displeasure. "After four cycles, open/closed [qualifiers], the time, effort, passion, and emotion myself, @TheeHyperactive, and @bluepanda_casts put in, we get replaced by two AI casters who even quote us," wrote caster Proto / Kai on X. "I get they are a part of the game, but yikes."
Another caster, Bluepanda, expressed frustration, stating, "For nearly seven years I've been repeatedly told that my work is valued and appreciated, only to then have the same people saying those things turn around and either completely ghost me or tell me they're going in a different direction with talent and that my services aren't needed."
The controversy highlights concerns about the increasing use of AI in the industry. Some players and casters see this as a worrying trend that could devalue human talent. "AI casters trained on the actual casters is devious, damn," commented fighting game caster Damascus. "Every day we keep moving towards the absolute slop era."
Embark Studios explained that the intention behind using Scotty and June was to introduce more players to The Finals' esports scene, leveraging familiarity with the in-game characters. However, the developer acknowledged the oversight in excluding the original talent. "The video was a highlight recap, and our team selected clips from the broadcast, wrote an original script and produced new commentary for Scotty and June," Embark stated. "However, leaving out the casters and talent who made that broadcast wasn’t the right call. We’ve taken the video down, and the AMER and EMEA recaps in the same format will no longer be released. We’re grateful to our talent for their candid feedback."
Oscar Lundberg, Competitive Experience and Community at Embark Studios, reiterated this sentiment on his personal X account, apologizing for the mistake and confirming that planned recaps for other regions would also not be released in the same format.
Despite the apology, some casters feel the response is insufficient. Bluepanda told IGN, "Embark saw no issue with this until they received overwhelming global backlash and even then their response was essentially, 'Whoopsie, we didn't think people would mind.' It says to me that they're not really sorry at all. I'm done with the game and esports as a whole at this stage, the effort we put in and the amount of bulls**t we have to deal with, especially in OCE, just isn't worth it anymore."
Proto further elaborated on the AI commentary's creation process, explaining that while the VOD itself wasn't fed into the AI, lines from the original commentary were incorporated. He warned that this practice could set a dangerous precedent, potentially leading to the replacement of human talent with cheaper AI alternatives.
"Opening that door is almost like Pandora's Box," Proto said. "As soon as it opens and people think that this is something that can be done, it creates problems for the talent who are pouring their heart and soul into these broadcasts. It just essentially takes away any kind of relevance from us in terms of, 'Why did we even bother?'"
Proto suggested that esports talent across various roles should consider forming a union to establish protections against such practices. "I think industry wide, we definitely need to implement some kind of protection for commentary teams as well as production teams," he stated. "There has to be some kind of something set up, whether it's a union, whether it's a global talent hiatus."
He concluded by describing the overall handling of the situation by Embark Studios as "a sh*t show" and called for sweeping changes, including a wider talent pool and support for local communities.
Embark Studios also utilizes AI for voice lines in its other title, Arc Raiders, though that application differs from the commentary controversy. In a previous interview, a design director noted that voice actors were contracted for AI use to enable dynamic in-game callouts.