Polygon has published its ranking of every mainline entry in the Legend of Zelda series. The ranking spans all 17 mainline titles, from the 1986 NES original to the 2024 Nintendo Switch release, Echoes of Wisdom.
The series, created by Shigeru Miyamoto, has consistently offered distinct visions of its core exploration concept since its inception. While many entries are true sequels, the series is marked by its willingness to reinvent itself, leading to a complex and often debated timeline.
Polygon's ranking methodology considered how enjoyable the games are to play in the present day, alongside their historical significance. The ranking excludes multiplayer titles like Four Swords and Four Swords Adventures, as well as spin-offs such as Link's Crossbow Training and Freshly Picked Tingle's Rosy Rupeeland. The Oracle of Seasons and Oracle of Ages games are counted as a single entry.
At the bottom of the ranking is Zelda 2: The Adventure of Link (1987). While considered an awkward experiment with lite RPG mechanics and side-scrolling combat, it is credited with influencing games like Castlevania 2: Simon's Quest and Shovel Knight. It is available on Nintendo Switch Online.
Following Zelda 2 is Phantom Hourglass (2007) for the Nintendo DS. This sequel to The Wind Waker introduced touch controls but suffered from uneven pacing and the repetitive Temple of the Ocean King. It is currently unavailable digitally.
Echoes of Wisdom (2024) takes the 15th spot. This title marks Princess Zelda's first starring role and features a unique mechanic of copying enemies and objects. Developed by Grezzo, it attempts to blend the player freedom of recent titles with a more traditional top-down Zelda structure, though it faces criticism for fiddly interfaces.
Twilight Princess (2006), released on GameCube and Wii, is ranked 14th. The game is noted for Link's wolf form and the inclusion of the character Midna, whose arc is considered a narrative highlight. A Wii U HD remaster is available, but the original versions are difficult to play.
The Game Boy Color duo Oracle of Ages and Oracle of Seasons (2001), developed by Capcom, are ranked 13th. These games are praised for their sophisticated design, with Ages focusing on time-travel puzzles and Seasons on action-oriented gameplay. They are available on Nintendo Switch Online.
Spirit Tracks (2009) for the Nintendo DS is ranked 12th. A follow-up to Phantom Hourglass, it features a steam train traversal mechanic and the unique dynamic of Link and Zelda adventuring together. It is currently unavailable digitally.
The original The Legend of Zelda (1986) for the NES is placed at number 11. Polygon notes its foundational role in open-world game design and its continued relevance, despite being opaque by modern standards. It is available on Nintendo Switch Online.
Skyward Sword (2011), available in an HD version on Nintendo Switch, is ranked 10th. Despite criticisms of its original motion controls and pacing, the game is lauded for its intricate dungeons and its role as a capstone to the Ocarina of Time-inspired era of Zelda design, emphasizing its romantic spirit.
A Link Between Worlds (2013) for the Nintendo 3DS is ranked 9th. This title innovates with Link's ability to merge into 2D surfaces, allowing traversal of Hyrule and its darker counterpart, Lorule. It is praised for its well-integrated touch controls and unique weapon rental system.
The Minish Cap (2004), developed by Capcom for the Game Boy Advance, holds the 8th position. This entry is highlighted for its charming art style, creative perspective shifts through shrinking mechanics, and well-designed dungeons. It is available on Nintendo Switch Online + Expansion Pack.