With the highly anticipated Grand Theft Auto 6 nearing its release, PC players are still awaiting a port announcement or a release date. However, the impending launch of Rockstar's latest open-world crime game has prompted a look back at Mafia: City of Lost Heaven, a title that released less than a year after Grand Theft Auto 3 and is considered by some to be a more prescient example of Rockstar's future direction than their own early work.

Set in the fictional 1930s Chicago-inspired city of Lost Heaven, the original Mafia game casts players as Tommy Angelo. The narrative follows his journey from a humble taxi driver who has a chance encounter with the Salieri crime family to becoming one of the organization's key enforcers in their conflict with rival gangs. The game draws heavily from cinematic influences, including The Godfather and Goodfellas, a practice also shared by Rockstar in their own titles. Illusion Softworks, the developer of Mafia, also focused on capturing the historical atmosphere of the Prohibition era. The story begins in the wake of the 1929 Wall Street Crash and progresses through the subsequent depression, with the in-game city evolving alongside the period. This evolution is reflected in changing architecture, the fluctuating occupancy of businesses, and most notably, the progression of automotive design on the streets, moving from Model T-esque vehicles to sleeker models.

The city of Lost Heaven was crafted with a dedication to realism that later became a hallmark of Rockstar's games. Players were expected to adhere to speed limits and traffic signals, with violations potentially resulting in fines if observed by law enforcement. The game also featured public transport options like streetcars and trams for navigation. Further immersive touches included realistic reloading animations where unfired bullets were discarded, and vehicles could run out of fuel if driven too far.

Mafia offered a more mature take on the open-world crime genre, even with a lower age rating than Grand Theft Auto. While Grand Theft Auto was undeniably more influential, its imitators often followed its tone and sensibilities. Saints Row, for example, began in a similar vein to GTA 3 before leaning into silliness and parody. For years, Mafia represented an alternative open-world path. However, as the Grand Theft Auto series has progressed, its design has increasingly mirrored the example set by Illusion Softworks. While still incorporating bombastic comedy, later GTA protagonists like Niko Belic and Michael de Santa, who are haunted by their pasts, offer richer characterizations than GTA 3's silent protagonist, Claude.

The Mafia series has continued with interesting concepts. Mafia 3 placed players in the role of Lincoln Clay, a Black Vietnam War veteran facing racism in a New Orleans-inspired setting during the Civil Rights Movement. The 2020 remake of the first Mafia game, Mafia: Definitive Edition, is praised for capturing the spirit of the original while enhancing the story. Despite the strengths of its sequels, the original Mafia is often considered the most innovative and forward-thinking entry in the series.

While Rockstar Games has consistently pushed the open-world genre forward with each release, the growing thematic and design similarities between their recent titles and Illusion Softworks' original Mafia suggest a convergence of vision. As Rockstar's games have matured, they have increasingly aligned with the thoughtful, grounded approach first showcased in Mafia: City of Lost Heaven.