In Grand Theft Auto 6, players face a significant early decision in the "Hey Arnold" quest: whether to spare or kill the character Arnold. This choice, while not drastically altering the main narrative, influences Jason's criminal profile and can lead to a financial reward later in the game. The mission involves confronting Arnold after a chase, where he pleads for his life and promises to disappear.
The Decision Point
After pursuing Arnold on foot, players will corner him near a pier. Arnold will then drop to his knees, begging not to be killed and expressing a desire to leave the criminal underworld. The player has the option to spare him by pressing X on PlayStation 5 or A on Xbox when prompted, or to end his life by firing their equipped weapon. It is also possible to run Arnold over with Brian's truck earlier in the encounter.
Consequences of the Choice
Killing Arnold provides a boost to Jason's reputation as a violent criminal. Conversely, sparing him grants a "restrained" bonus, contributing to a more professional, non-violent criminal profile. Other actions, such as beating or shooting Arnold in the body, result in a "ruthless" stat boost, but do not align with either extreme reputation.
While this single choice won't definitively set Jason's criminal profile, it contributes to the overall direction players choose for their character. For those aiming for a specific playstyle, aligning this decision with their goals is recommended.
Later Payout
Sparing Arnold also has a financial benefit. After some in-game time passes, typically around Chapter 4, Arnold sends Jason a sum of $10,000 as a thank you for sparing his life. This reward is delivered via a text message from Brian, confirming the payment and its availability for collection. The exact timing may vary depending on player actions and story progression.