Harvey Smith, a pivotal figure in the immersive sim genre, looks back on his career, which began with a "brush with greatness" working on System Shock and continued through landmark titles like Deus Ex and the Dishonored series. His experiences underscore a consistent dedication to the principles of immersive simulation, even when faced with industry pressures to pursue more commercially viable, but creatively divergent, projects.
Smith's formative years in game development were deeply influenced by early immersive sims like Ultima Underworld. His involvement with System Shock during his time in quality assurance provided crucial insight into the development philosophy of Looking Glass Studios. Later, working with Warren Spector at Ion Storm Austin, he applied these lessons to Deus Ex. This passion for creating player-driven experiences, where narrative and mechanics intertwine, became the driving force behind Arkane Studios, which he co-founded with Raphaël Colantonio.
During Arkane's independent years, the studio frequently faced decisions that tested its commitment to immersive sims. Smith recalls external pressures to develop DLC for unrelated action shooters, offers that were often lucrative but misaligned with Arkane's core identity. "We'd be like, 'Yeah, but we don't like those. We don't know how to do them well, and we think that game is dumb,'" Smith stated, highlighting the studio's willingness to "gamble the company on doing what we are known for."
This unwavering focus, though financially precarious at times, eventually garnered recognition within the industry. Smith recounts how Arkane's reputation for crafting intricate, exploration-rewarding first-person experiences led to an opportunity to contribute to BioShock 2 when the studio was in a tight spot. "In a sense the purity was more valuable than the jack-of-all-trades," he reflected. "There are many ways to fail, many ways to succeed. But specializing in what you love is not a bad path."
The studio's venture into co-op looter-shooting with Redfall proved to be a significant misstep. Smith acknowledged that the game "did not come together" and that Arkane "never should have been working on a games-as-a-service game." Co-founder Ben Horne cited external factors like the game's $70 price point and the ongoing console wars, but ultimately agreed the core issue was developing a product outside Arkane's established expertise. The experience reinforced the importance of returning to their strengths.
Following the closure of Arkane Austin, Smith and Horne established Black Pony Immersive, a studio explicitly dedicated to creating immersive sims. "Getting back to what we do best was the number one priority," Horne explained. The studio aims to uphold the legacy of pioneering immersive sim developers like Looking Glass Studios and Ion Storm.
Black Pony's upcoming debut title is expected to embody the hallmarks of the genre: first-person gameplay that blends shooter, stealth, and RPG elements, emphasizing player creativity, narrative depth, and atmospheric world-building. Smith described the development philosophy as a balance between honoring the genre's established conventions and innovating to surprise players. "On one hand, I want to pay off those expectations. On the other hand, I want to exceed them," he said.
Smith also touched on the thematic underpinnings of his work, noting how games like Dishonored explore systems of power and exploitation, while Deus Ex served as a political awakening influenced by his collaboration with Warren Spector. He believes that even familiar gameplay mechanics can be revitalized through novel fictional contexts, citing Dishonored's possession power—initially conceived as a riff on Hitman's disguises—as an example of how new mechanics can emerge from adapting established ideas to a new setting.
Looking forward, Smith hopes Black Pony Immersive will continue the tradition of impactful immersive sim development. "Let's hope Black Pony's not the one trick pony, right?" he quipped, emphasizing the studio's ambition to innovate within their chosen genre.