Katsuhiro Harada, formerly director of the Tekken series, has voiced strong criticism of the Xbox Series S, stating he wishes the console had not been released. Harada shared these sentiments during a developer panel at the Console Game Developers Conference in South Korea, with a senior Xbox official reportedly in attendance.
Speaking at the event, moderated by former Sony president Shuhei Yoshida, Harada explained that while consoles offer advantages for fighting game development, the Xbox Series S presents unique difficulties. He described the console as having "awkwardly lower performance" compared to the Series X, despite their similar appearance. This disparity, he noted, creates extra work for developers when porting games.
"Low memory is an issue, but the hardest part is that it's a device so similar to Series X while having awkwardly lower performance," Harada stated. He drew a comparison to porting games to the Nintendo Switch, where developers can adjust their mindset for a distinct platform. In contrast, he feels the Series S requires additional optimization efforts without a clear separation from the Series X.
Harada also highlighted the impact on player experience and developer support. He mentioned that in markets like the US, the Series S has a larger user base than the Series X. This necessitates that developers avoid cutting corners on optimization. However, he noted that Series S users often direct complaints about lower texture resolution or other graphical differences to the developers, rather than Microsoft.
CD Projekt Red associate game director Paweł Sasko, also on the panel, acknowledged the challenges but offered a more balanced perspective. He pointed out that optimizing for weaker hardware like the Series S can lead to improved performance across all platforms. Sasko cited Cyberpunk 2077's optimization for the Nintendo Switch, where work done for that version benefited other platforms as well. He also suggested that the Series S's affordability contributes to market expansion.
Despite Sasko's points, Harada humorously worried that his comments might reassure Microsoft, potentially leading to a similar, lower-spec successor for future Xbox generations. The discussion concluded with optimism from Shift Up's DongKi Lee, who expressed eagerness to work with future Xbox hardware, provided early access to development kits.