The season one finale of Lanterns, episode eight, provides a conclusion that largely stays true to the narrative the series has been building, even if it eschews significant plot twists. While expectations for shocking reveals regarding Hal Jordan's killer and potential resurrections should be tempered, the episode delivers an emotionally resonant ending.
The finale opens with a flashback to 2016, establishing that the core of the series remains a small-town murder mystery, even as the narrative touches upon larger cosmic elements. It is revealed that Noah is a Manhunter and orchestrated Sinestro's release from prison with the intention of obtaining a Lantern to use against the Guardians. This revelation wraps up many of the season's lingering questions.
The role of Sinestro, a prominent Green Lantern villain, is notably minimal throughout the season, and his presence in the finale primarily serves to provide exposition. The review notes a disappointment in the underutilization of Sinestro's potential as a significant antagonist and a missed opportunity to explore his history with the Lantern Corps within the DC Universe.
However, the arc involving Noah is considered successful, with the Manhunter reveal working within the context of the story, regardless of its predictability. The series also ties up the mystery of Hal's killer with the reveal that Kerry was responsible, driven by a desire to protect the alien beings she cared for. Kelly Macdonald's performance during her confession is highlighted as a strong point.
Aaron Pierre's portrayal of John Stewart in the finale is also praised, particularly his nuanced performance as John grapples with revelations and finds peace. The episode effectively culminates the season-long tension between John and Hal, culminating in a poignant passing of the torch moment. Kyle Chandler's performance as Hal, especially in his final words to John, is noted for its emotional impact.
While the finale does not find a way to retain Hal in a potential second season, either through the Halogram or resurrection, it successfully establishes John Stewart's destiny as Earth's Green Lantern. The episode is seen as a satisfying conclusion to the season's narrative, even if the exploration of John's acceptance of fear could have been more developed. The final scenes effectively position John for future endeavors within the DCU.
The season one finale of Lanterns concludes on a largely cohesive and satisfying note, according to the review. Despite the predictability of some plot developments, the episode carries narrative weight and delivers strong performances from Pierre, Chandler, and Macdonald. The season is credited with establishing a compelling new hero for the DC Universe, regardless of whether a second season is greenlit.