Pikmin 4's recent "Nintendo Switch 2 Edition" upgrade, which promised enhanced visuals, voice commands for Oatchi, and new bonus levels, has ignited fan fury. Priced at $10, the update has been met with significant backlash, with many players deeming the improvements insufficient and, in some aspects, detrimental to the original experience.
The "Pikmin 4 Nintendo Switch 2 Edition + Dandori Academy" currently holds a user score of 2.1 on Metacritic, a stark contrast to the base game's 8.9. Recurring complaints center on the lack of substantial technical enhancements, with users reporting that frame rates remain at 30 FPS and loading screens have become noticeably longer than in the original version. One 0/10 review lamented, "charging customers for almost no content nor technical enhancements (in fact, load times are even longer on NSW2 – it’s a disgrace!)".
Critics also point out that the new content largely reuses existing maps from the base game, with limited rewards. A 1/10 review described the upgrade as "essentially a paid downgrade," highlighting that "the framerate went from an consistent 30 FPS to an inconsistent 30 FPS." While some acknowledge a higher resolution and improved draw distance, they argue these benefits do not justify the cost, especially as older textures have not been significantly upscaled.
However, not all players share this sentiment. Some on the Pikmin subreddit have called the user scores "overdramatic," suggesting the upgrade aligns with other "Switch 2 Edition" releases from Nintendo. Despite this, few are actively defending the new edition, with most comments leaning towards the upgrade being less catastrophic than its scores imply.
For those who have not yet played Pikmin 4, the "Switch 2 Edition" may represent the definitive way to experience the game. However, for existing players seeking more content, the value proposition of this paid upgrade appears questionable, with some advising to "keep your Pikmin planted and hold out for Pikmin 5."