The Nintendo Switch 2, while receiving upgraded editions of some Switch titles, has seen mixed reception. While games like Kirby and the Forgotten Land have been praised for new content and performance improvements, the recently released Switch 2 version of Pikmin 4, titled Pikmin 4: Nintendo Switch 2 Edition + Dandori Academy, is facing fan backlash.
This upgrade, which adds new levels and higher-resolution graphics for $10, currently holds a user score of 1.9 out of 10 on Metacritic, a stark contrast to the original version's 8.9 user rating. Users are citing performance regressions, including frame rate drops and extended load times, with some claiming the new version is essentially a "paid downgrade."
"Actively makes the game worse," one user review stated, echoing sentiments about longer load times, frame drops, and glitches compared to the original Switch version. Beyond technical complaints, some players find the new Dandori Academy levels repetitive, noting that they reuse areas from the main game. Despite these criticisms, the higher resolution and enhanced voice support for Oatchi have been acknowledged as positive aspects by some.
Conversely, some players on platforms like Reddit argue that the negative reviews are disproportionate. They suggest that while maps may be reused, new enemy placements and other changes offer a fresh experience. Nevertheless, the perceived light touch of the Pikmin 4 upgrade compared to other Switch 2 editions has sparked concerns among fans regarding the prioritization of the series. While Pikmin 5 remains unannounced, upcoming Pikmin shorts offer an alternative to anticipate.