The release of Star Wars: Episode II – Attack of the Clones in 2002 was met with a wide spectrum of fan reactions, documented in online discussions from the era. While many fans expressed excitement and a sense of awe, others voiced disappointment with various aspects of the film.

Numerous viewers praised the film as an improvement over its predecessor, The Phantom Menace. Specific highlights frequently mentioned include the introduction of CGI Yoda, whose combat capabilities were a significant talking point. "CG Yoda is brilliant," one user declared, with others noting that the character's fighting prowess with a lightsaber was a standout moment. The action sequences, such as the Coruscant chase and the duel between Obi-Wan Kenobi and Jango Fett, were also frequently lauded as thrilling and well-executed. The final confrontation with Dooku was described by one fan as "fabulous – best Jedi fights ever."

The performances of the cast, particularly Hayden Christensen as Anakin Skywalker and Ewan McGregor as Obi-Wan Kenobi, received positive attention. Christensen was often cited as a strong fit for Anakin, capturing the character's whiny and evolving nature. Natalie Portman's portrayal of Padmé Amidala also drew praise, with some noting her improved delivery compared to earlier scenes.

However, criticism was also prevalent. Pacing issues, especially in the film's opening act, were a common complaint, with some describing the first 45 to 60 minutes as rushed and filled with dry exposition. The dialogue was a frequent target, with many finding it corny or boring. The love story between Anakin and Padmé, while appreciated by some for its brevity, was seen by others as lacking chemistry or being too "cheesy."

The visual effects, while largely impressive, also drew some mixed opinions. While the CGI Yoda was a hit, some viewers felt that other effects, particularly those in the arena sequence, were not up to par. The reliance on CGI was a point of contention for some, who felt it detracted from the Star Wars feel or made the film appear less grounded.

Some fans drew comparisons to the original trilogy, with a recurring sentiment being that Attack of the Clones lacked the same spirit, fun, or wonderment. These critics often felt the film was technically flawed and lacked a human touch, with some questioning George Lucas's directorial capabilities. Conversely, many argued that the prequel trilogy was intentionally different from the original, offering a "whole new experience."

Despite the divided opinions, a significant portion of the initial audience expressed immense satisfaction, with many considering Attack of the Clones the best Star Wars film to date. The anticipation for Episode III and the unfolding of the larger narrative arc were also key elements driving fan engagement and discussion.