James Gunn and Peter Safran are no longer leading DC Studios, and their ambitious 8-10 year plan for the DC Universe, dubbed Gods and Monsters: Chapter One, never saw its intended Caped Crusader on screen. While Gunn introduced new iterations of Superman, Green Lantern, Supergirl, and Lex Luthor, the absence of Batman, DC's most popular and bankable character, may have significantly impacted the studio's trajectory and Gunn and Safran's tenure.

Gunn referred to Batman and Wonder Woman as DC's "diamond characters," yet their lack of a cinematic presence meant other characters, even Superman, had to carry the weight of establishing the new DCU. While Superman performed adequately at the box office, the studio faced critical and commercial disappointment with Supergirl, further highlighting Batman's potential importance.

Despite the development of Batman: The Brave and the Bold, intended as the DCU's live-action Batman introduction, the project remained in flux. Simultaneously, Matt Reeves' The Batman: Part II, a project unconnected to the DCU, continued in development. Gunn had expressed support for Reeves' vision and allowed him considerable time, while keeping the DCU's own Batman film on the back burner.

Gunn acknowledged Batman as his "biggest issue in all of DC right now" in June 2025, a sentiment that persisted since the announcement of Gods and Monsters. This was particularly notable given the transition from the Snyderverse, which saw multiple Batmen—Ben Affleck, Michael Keaton, and even George Clooney's Bruce Wayne—appear in The Flash.

Andy Muschietti, who directed The Flash, was initially attached to direct Batman: The Brave and the Bold. However, following The Flash's box office failure, the attachment became uncertain, with Gunn and Safran often citing the need for a revised script. Christina Hodson was the last known screenwriter to work on the screenplay.

The project's challenges were evident, with Gunn stating in September 2025 that "plenty of things are in flux" regarding Batman: The Brave and the Bold. His previously stated enthusiasm for Batman's son, Damian Wayne, also seemed to wane, with cryptic remarks about the character's inclusion. Gunn had indicated he had an actor in mind for the DCU's Batman, who would be similar in age to David Corenswet's Superman, but has since shut down casting rumors. The closest fans have come to seeing the DCU's Batman was an animated cameo in Creature Commandos.

Batman: The Brave and the Bold was conceived during a period of transition between studio leadership and shared universes, and its development seems to have stalled indefinitely. Sources indicated that The Brave and the Bold was planned to move forward once Matt Reeves' The Batman: Part II wrapped production, with the aim of avoiding audience confusion by not releasing two different Batman films concurrently.

It is speculated that The Batman: Part II might be the final entry in Matt Reeves' Batman saga, given Robert Pattinson's aging and potential commitment to other major roles like James Bond. The significant gap between The Batman and its sequel suggests that the new DC Studios leadership may seek to introduce their own Batman, unburdened by previous storylines, once The Batman: Part II is released in 2028.