Embark Studios, the developer behind the popular FPS game The Finals, has ignited a firestorm within the esports community after replacing human casters with artificial intelligence voices for a highlight reel of the game's Grand Major esports tournament. The now-removed video featured footage from the APAC closed qualifiers, but instead of the voices of the casters who worked the matches, viewers heard AI commentators named Scotty and June.
The incident has drawn sharp criticism, with many in the professional esports circuit calling for greater worker protections and potential unionization efforts.
Proto, one of the casters who was replaced in the highlight reel, voiced his disappointment on social media. He noted the significant time, effort, passion, and emotion he and his colleagues invested in the qualifiers, only to be supplanted by AI. "I get they are apart of the game but yikes," he stated.
Oscar Lundberg, community and competitive operations lead at Embark Studios, issued an apology. He explained that the intention was to generate more casual interest in The Finals esports leading up to the main event. However, he acknowledged that the work of the human talent deserved recognition and should have been included. "The work of our talent deserved to be included and highlighted, and it wasn’t," Lundberg wrote.
This move by Embark Studios follows a pattern of AI integration within The Finals. Upon its launch in 2023, the game faced scrutiny for its use of AI text-to-speech for voice acting, a feature the developers have openly embraced. Andreas Almström, the game's audio director, previously stated that AI text-to-speech technology has reached a point of high quality and allows for rapid iteration on new ideas.
Earlier this year, The Finals introduced a "Dynamic Commentary" feature, which enables AI commentators to call out players by name during matches. This in-game integration may have signaled a broader intent to explore AI applications in other areas, including tournament broadcasts.
Esports professionals, many of whom have seen their jobs impacted by declining studio investment over the past few years, were quick to address the issue. Proto expressed a need for industry-wide protections for commentary and production teams to safeguard their livelihoods.