The Legend of Zelda franchise was in "dire straits" and experiencing shrinking interest from its player base prior to the release of 2017's Breath of the Wild, according to two former Nintendo of America marketing leads. Kit Ellis, the company's ex-director of social media marketing, and former public relations manager Krysta Yang discussed the series' trajectory on their podcast.
Ellis stated that focus groups revealed feedback indicating a "dwindling" fanbase and a failure to attract new players. "Interest in the audience was getting smaller and smaller" with each successive entry, necessitating a "dramatic" shift. Yang echoed this sentiment, adding that the series "was in dire straits. They were selling, like, nothing."
This perspective contrasts with what the sources describe as "revisionist history" suggesting the Zelda team removed series staples like classic dungeons and linear worlds at a time of peak popularity. The sales figures lend some credence to the notion of a plateau before Breath of the Wild's success. For comparison, Twilight Princess sold approximately 8 million copies, while Skyward Sword sold around 3 million. In contrast, Breath of the Wild achieved over 34 million sales, a figure that also led to its ambitious sequel, Tears of the Kingdom, and influenced the design of the 2D title, Echoes of Wisdom.