Etsy is facing significant backlash from its sellers following a recent update to its terms of service that allows the platform and its partners to use user-generated content for training artificial intelligence and machine learning models. In protest, numerous vendors have closed their online stores, with some encouraging others to join the boycott.
The contentious clause, found in Section 5, Part C of Etsy's terms of use, states that users grant the company and its third-party partners the right to use their content for "develop, train, test and improve artificial intelligence and machine learning technologies." This has been interpreted by many sellers as a move that could lead to their creative work being used to train AI systems that might replicate or devalue their offerings.
In response to the growing outcry, Etsy vice president of customer operations James Ossman issued a statement attempting to clarify the policy. He asserted that the company does not intend to use seller content to train AI models designed to copy original work or replace creativity. Instead, Ossman explained, the content is used for functions such as translating listings for international buyers, featuring items in marketing campaigns, and developing shop optimization tools. He also stated that third-party partnerships are undertaken carefully to protect seller content and data.
However, critics point out that Ossman's clarifications are not reflected in the legal text of the terms of service. Furthermore, many users have expressed frustration that there is no apparent opt-out option for sellers who wish to prevent their work from being used for AI training, forcing them to either comply or cease selling on the platform. This situation stands in contrast to Etsy's earlier decision to ban AI-generated items, a move that was intended to foster trust and ensure fair representation of craftsmanship on the platform.
The controversy highlights a broader concern among creators and consumers regarding the increasing integration of AI technologies and the potential implications for intellectual property and artistic integrity. The forceful reaction from Etsy sellers underscores a growing demand for clearer policies and greater control over how creative content is utilized in the age of artificial intelligence.