The European Commission's proposed Digital Fairness Act is poised to significantly alter video game monetization practices, potentially impacting the global market. The Act, which targets issues like loot boxes and virtual currencies, particularly concerning minors, is expected to become law between 2028 and 2029.
Key provisions include disabling paid virtual currencies by default for players under 18, requiring parental approval for activation, and prohibiting the sale of paid loot boxes to minors altogether. Furthermore, games must offer users a way to disable paid loot boxes and clearly display the probability of obtaining items from them. These regulations carry substantial fines for non-compliance, potentially reaching up to six percent of a company's worldwide annual turnover.
George Osborn, a games business expert and author of the Video Games Industry Memo newsletter, views these changes as a "really big" regulatory shift that will concern major publishers like EA, Xbox, Activision Blizzard, and PlayStation. Implementing these rules presents logistical challenges, such as accurately identifying minors and providing a universal "master switch" for loot box disablement. Osborn noted that for games like EA Sports FC Ultimate Team, the ability for players to opt out of loot boxes could impact revenue, although this mode is somewhat compartmentalized. For games where random paid rewards are integral to their design, such as certain card games, the implications could be even more profound, potentially requiring complete redesigns.
The Act also mandates that virtual currency purchases clearly display their cost in local currency, adding another layer of complexity. Beyond loot boxes, the Act addresses broader consumer protections, including making subscription services like Xbox Live and PlayStation Plus easier to cancel and requiring human customer service options. While these rules are legally binding only within the EU, their influence is expected to extend globally. Companies seeking to sell games in the substantial European market will need to comply.
Osborn predicts that, similar to the EU's mandate for USB-C chargers or rules influencing the design of Nintendo Switch 2 batteries, developers will likely adopt a single, compliant design for all markets to streamline production. "There's going to be a strong likelihood that some of the design features will remain within the games because it's easiest to work off a single universal version," he stated.
The Act's impact could also inspire similar regulations worldwide, as other policy makers may look to the EU's consumer protection model for solutions to persistent issues like loot boxes. The precedent set by a major regulatory bloc like the European Union could encourage other regions to adopt similar measures, especially since companies that have already implemented compliance solutions for the EU may find it easier to extend them globally.
Osborn anticipates that this will push loot boxes further to the periphery of game monetization. While some prominent games may retain them, he suggests a broader trend towards their reduction, noting that many companies have already begun to distance themselves from loot boxes due to reputational concerns. The requirement for a prominent "off-switch" is expected to deter new implementations. Although certain business models, like those deeply reliant on loot boxes or card-based mechanics, may struggle to adapt, the overall landscape is likely to shift. "And more broadly what this marks is a much wider crackdown on the way that video games monetise their players," Osborn concluded. "As you start to see that crackdown come into force, game developers are going to have to think much more carefully about how the design decisions they make don't just interact with ethical practices, but actually with legal practices too."