In 1998, the PC graphics card market was a crowded landscape with 47 companies vying for dominance. Today, that number has dwindled to just two: Nvidia and AMD. This dramatic consolidation, driven by rapid product cycles, market shifts, and the dot-com bubble's burst, fundamentally reshaped the industry.

A Crowded Field

In 1998, choosing a graphics card for a gaming PC was a challenge due to the sheer number of options. The market for 3D graphics chips was booming, with 47 companies designing or selling these components. This fierce competition drove innovation, but it also meant that many smaller players struggled to keep pace. At the turn of the millennium, only 15 companies remained, and by the mid-2000s, the market was largely a duopoly between Nvidia and ATI (now part of AMD).

Nvidia, though now a titan, was not the clear leader in 1998. Research firm 4th Wave placed ATI at the top for that year, followed by S3 and Intel. Nvidia ranked fourth, just ahead of 3dfx, the company that had popularized 3D gaming on PCs with its Voodoo cards. The rapid pace of technological advancement, with new chips released roughly every six months, favored companies with significant capital and the ability to iterate quickly. Nvidia proved adept at this strategy, a feat few others could match.

The Collapse Begins

Many of the early departures were not directly due to Nvidia's actions. The increasing complexity and cost of designing 3D accelerators proved too much for established 2D chip makers. Companies like Tseng Labs and Rendition sold their graphics divisions or were acquired. Nvidia's own 1999 IPO prospectus highlighted the risk of missing PC manufacturer release schedules, which typically had two cycles per year. The company structured itself to meet these demands, launching successful products like the GeForce 256 and GeForce 3.

S3, once the second-largest graphics chip maker, noted in its 1999 annual report that a graphics chip's market life was typically 12 to 18 months, and even a few months' delay could cost crucial design wins. Companies releasing only one major chip annually found themselves launching against refreshed competitor products, a significant disadvantage.

3dfx's Downfall

The fate of 3dfx serves as a prime example. The failure of its next-generation chip, Rampage, to ship was a critical blow. Furthermore, its proprietary Glide programming interface, once a significant advantage, became less relevant as Microsoft's Direct3D and OpenGL drivers improved, allowing games to run on a wider range of hardware. 3dfx's decision to acquire STB Systems and prioritize its own cards for Voodoo3 chips alienated partners like Diamond and Creative, who had built their gaming lines on Voodoo products. This forced these partners to seek chips from Nvidia. The company's financial struggles, including losing $100.5 million in the second quarter of 2000, ultimately led to its assets being sold to Nvidia in late 2000.

Intel's Foray and Retreat

Intel's entry into the discrete graphics market with its i740 chip in 1998 also contributed to the market consolidation. While Intel eventually pulled out of standalone desktop graphics, its integrated graphics solutions on motherboards gained significant market share by 2001, impacting companies like S3, Trident, and SiS, which relied on the budget market. Intel later attempted a comeback with its Arc Alchemist GPUs in 2022, but despite driver improvements, it has struggled to gain significant market share, currently holding around 2% of shipments.

The Duopoly Endures

ATI survived and eventually became part of AMD due to its established market position and its strategy of manufacturing its own graphics cards, which provided greater revenue and margin control. The company also aggressively acquired talent from rival firms. For two decades, Nvidia and AMD (through its acquisition of ATI) dominated the discrete GPU market. While AMD briefly surpassed Nvidia in discrete graphics shipments in 2010, its financial struggles following the ATI acquisition meant it couldn't consistently compete on research and development spending. This allowed Nvidia to solidify its lead, particularly with the introduction of dedicated ray tracing hardware and AI-focused Tensor cores in its RTX cards.

The consolidation has had significant consequences for consumers, with a duopoly leading to higher prices and limited choices. The market, once vibrant with 47 competitors, now sees Nvidia controlling approximately 90% of shipments, with much of its revenue coming from data centers rather than gaming. This leaves PC gamers in a difficult position, with few options and persistently high prices, exacerbated by factors like the ongoing AI-driven demand for memory.