Generative AI remains a contentious topic within the video game industry, with a new report indicating that 40% of developers are currently using these tools, yet more than half believe the technology has a detrimental effect on the industry.
The findings come from the latest State of the Game Industry report by the Game Developer's Conference, which surveyed over 2,600 industry professionals. This represents a slight increase from the previous year, where 36% of respondents reported using generative AI.
The report also noted demographic trends in AI adoption. Developers over the age of 45 were more likely to use generative AI, with 54% in that age bracket reporting its use. The data also suggests men use AI tools more frequently than women, and that indie developers are less inclined to adopt these technologies compared to those working in larger studios on premium, free-to-play, or mobile-exclusive titles.
Among developers who utilize generative AI, the most common application is for research and brainstorming, cited by nearly three-quarters of users. Over half (56%) use it for code generation and debugging. Adoption drops significantly for more creative tasks, with only 22% using it for concept art and visual ideation, and a mere 7% for player-facing features.
Despite the increased usage, a prevailing negative sentiment surrounds generative AI's impact on the games industry. 55% of surveyed professionals believe the technology is having a negative effect, a figure that has seen a substantial increase over the past two years. In contrast, only 8% of respondents feel that generative AI is having a positive impact, while 35% perceive the effect as mixed.
The report suggests that game industry professionals are developing a more nuanced perspective on generative AI, moving away from an absolute stance. However, new concerns have emerged regarding potential skill atrophy and a decline in professional and personal development among users. This is coupled with a growing skepticism towards using generative AI for player-facing features.
The increasing prevalence of AI is becoming unavoidable. Casual searches may now technically involve AI, and the impact of AI tools, particularly in coding, is becoming more evident. Platforms like Steam and itch.io are grappling with a surge in low-quality AI-generated games, while the use of AI among developers has ignited significant debate within the community.
Future shifts in developer sentiment may be influenced by broader trends in the AI industry. Following a period of rapid expansion, major technology companies have faced scandals and increased investor scrutiny regarding the long-term profitability of generative tools. The coming year could prove critical in determining the trajectory of generative AI within the games industry and the tech sector at large.