Sony has successfully defeated a significant class-action lawsuit in the United Kingdom that accused the company of operating a near-monopoly through its PlayStation Store. The legal challenge, brought forth by consumer advocate Alex Neill on behalf of nine million UK PlayStation owners, was dismissed by a London court. Had Sony lost, the lawsuit could have cost the company as much as $2.6 billion.
The case, which had been ongoing since 2022, argued that Sony's exclusive control over digital game sales on its platform constituted an abuse of its dominant position. The plaintiffs contended that by preventing third-party retailers from selling digital PlayStation games, Sony forced consumers to pay inflated prices for digital titles and in-game content. The lawsuit cited Sony's practice of taking a 30 percent cut from each sale as evidence of this alleged monopoly.
This ruling follows a previous attempt by Sony to have the case thrown out in 2023, which was unsuccessful. The situation appeared more precarious for Sony earlier this year when a similar case in California resulted in a $7.8 billion judgment against the company. Reports indicated that Sony's dominance in digital game sales on its platform was only expected to grow as physical media sales decline.
However, the Competition Appeal Tribunal in London ultimately rejected the core arguments of the UK lawsuit. The tribunal ruled that the claim failed to establish that PlayStation infringed competition law. The defense presented by Sony included the broader competitive landscape of consoles like Xbox and Nintendo, as well as the continued availability of physical game versions. The court also noted that allowing third-party stores could pose security risks, an argument that had previously been used unsuccessfully by Google in its legal battles.
Furthermore, the tribunal found that the claimant had not proven Sony's profits were excessive, likely influenced by the industry-standard practice of a 30 percent revenue share. Despite this victory, Sony still faces similar legal challenges in other countries, including Holland, Portugal, and Mexico, the outcomes of which remain uncertain.