Ashes of the Singularity 2 offers a grand scale for real-time strategy fans, delivering on the promise of colossal armies clashing across vast battlefields, much like its predecessor. However, the sequel struggles to build upon the original's strengths, failing to address its weaknesses while introducing new issues, particularly a disappointing campaign and the obtrusive use of generative AI.

Commanding the Masses

The game's most notable success lies in its army management. Units are automatically grouped into armies during recruitment, and these armies can be controlled as single entities, moving and attacking with surprising intuition. This system simplifies overseeing multiple forces, a significant improvement for games of this scale. Replenishing destroyed units with a button press or automatic reinforcement further streamlines gameplay, encouraging strategic placement of production buildings near the front lines.

Base building follows familiar RTS conventions, but unit recruitment and army control are where Ashes of the Singularity 2 shines. UI elements are accessible through shortcuts or a single menu layer, minimizing time spent navigating menus. However, this convenience comes at the cost of finer control, with unit recruitment bottlenecked to one unit per building type. Aerial units also prove to be a weakness, easily countered and prone to falling behind ground forces in mixed armies.

A Disappointing Campaign

The game introduces a new faction, the United Earth Forces (UEF), but it is described as the least interesting. Composed of conventional tanks, jets, and soldiers, the UEF lacks the distinctiveness of the other factions' mechs and robotic insects. The UEF's primary utility comes from its mobile base tank, but this feature is not enough to make the faction fun.

The UEF is also the sole focus of the game's campaign, which spans 10 missions. Roughly half of these are rudimentary tutorials with passive AI. The latter half, set across various solar system locations, offers slightly more challenging AI, with the final two missions providing notable resistance. Despite these improvements, the campaign missions are described as unambitious and lacking in twists. The overall campaign length is estimated at four to five hours, which is considered insufficient.

Ashes of the Singularity 2 fight

The campaign's narrative is also criticized as a poorly executed philosophical lecture. The story struggles with its portrayal of humans, AI, and post-human constructs, with characters often delivering lengthy monologues about AI threats and identity. This narrative weakness is exacerbated by the game's use of generative AI.

The Specter of AI

Oxide Games has disclosed the use of AI for post-processing effects and animation in campaign cutscenes, as well as for compositing some 3D assets. Additionally, AI-generated stock voices from ElevenLabs were used for unit barks, notifications, and minor characters. However, the reviewer suspects further AI integration, noting that character portraits and voice lines appear to be AI-generated. The visual style is described as having a "horrible, plasticky AI sheen," and the voice acting is often tonally off, detracting from the narrative.

This reliance on AI is seen as a missed opportunity, especially given the RTS genre's history of strong cinematic storytelling in titles like Warcraft 3 and StarCraft 2. The reviewer suggests that even low-budget, human-created content would be preferable to the game's "airy, inhuman waffle."

Ashes of the Singularity 2 fight

With the campaign deemed a write-off, players are left with multiplayer and skirmish modes. Skirmish mode is where Ashes of the Singularity traditionally excels, offering a better experience than the campaign. However, the maps lack personality, and the overall pacing is too slow. Battles can become attrition-heavy, and the impact of units in combat is not as pronounced as expected for a game of such scale. The game's impressive technical achievement in managing large armies is acknowledged, but the overall package, including one new faction and multiplayer, is considered insufficient for a sequel after a decade.

Ashes of the Singularity 2 fight