Paul Thomas Anderson’s concert movie, Cameron Winter at Carnegie Hall, is a stripped-back documentary focused on a minimalist solo performance by Geese frontman Cameron Winter. At 24 years old, Winter sits at a piano on a darkened stage, angled away from the audience, creating a subtle mystery that director Anderson complements with his camera work, occasionally operated by producer Benny Safdie. The film's impact will likely depend on the viewer's familiarity with Winter's music, but the documentary achieves a grounded tactility.
Anderson opens with the sounds of mobile ticket scanners before cutting from empty seats to a full crowd, building anticipation. This approach differs from his earlier concert film, Junun, which used drones to capture musicians in Jodhpur. Cameron Winter at Carnegie Hall feels more compassionate, perhaps due to Anderson's greater maturity as a documentarian or a closer connection to the music.
The dim concert space is brought to life by the grain of Anderson’s 35mm film, creating a fluid and rhythmic image. The film is immersive, occasionally featuring audience members using their cellphones. Between wide shots of Winter at the piano and close-ups of him by the microphone, the frame conjures imagery from Winter's song "Try as I May," where he sings about private ceremonies in dark rooms.
Winter's poetry, both religious and self-effacing, speaks through his music without overt directorial flourishes. Intermittent lights illuminate a sparse backdrop, revealing glimpses of an empty space. Mostly, the frame focuses on close-ups of Winter immersed in song. Even those unfamiliar with his music may be drawn to his dreamlike reflections, which are peppered with humor through piano playing and interactions with the set itself.
The film is a soothing concert experience, suitable for zoning out or even falling asleep to. The music has a modern, alternative vibe, though the performance itself is straightforward and classical. Anderson’s approach, with slow zooms and occasional hand-held shots, is reverential towards the young musician. The focus remains on the music, which resonates within Carnegie Hall’s historic walls more than on the sparsely decorated stage. Anderson largely stays out of the way, even with the camera positioned close to Winter, only revealing himself in the closing credits after Winter’s 72-minute performance concludes.
Cameron Winter at Carnegie Hall received a "great" rating, with IGN praising it as an inviting, minimalist concert film about a New York folk singer. The film's verdict highlights its affecting nature, with the darkened performance space coming alive in a dreamlike fashion.