EA Sports FC 27 stands at a crossroads, presenting a review in progress that highlights both significant advancements and persistent shortcomings. While the game introduces a sophisticated and intuitive Tactics system that effectively mirrors real-world football strategies, it concurrently struggles with the long-standing issues of computer-controlled player behavior and the unconvincing implementation of new open-world elements in "The Grounds." This duality results in a title that takes notable steps forward in gameplay mechanics while simultaneously regressing in other areas.
The addition of "The Grounds," an open-world hub reminiscent of NBA 2K's The Neighborhood, attempts to foster a more communal online experience. However, the execution falls short of its potential. The expansive, visually busy environment often feels unnecessary, with simple menu systems proving more efficient for accessing game modes. Despite its function as an active lobby for matchmaking and player discovery, "The Grounds" is marred by framerate drops and unnatural character animations that detract from immersion. The mode is further hampered by unskippable cutscenes and stilted voice acting. Even familiar characters like Alex Hunter, voiced by Adetomiwa Edun, and Kylian Mbappé deliver lines with a detached, mechanical cadence that undermines their impact.
Tactical Depth Shines
In contrast to the uninspired open world, the expanded Tactics system in EA Sports FC 27 is a standout addition. This new strategy system offers players granular control over team behavior across different phases of play. It moves beyond basic formations and instructions, clearly articulating the purpose, strengths, and weaknesses of various tactical approaches. This depth is particularly beneficial when building strategies around individual player attributes. For example, a deeper defensive approach suits a player like Noussair Mazraoui, allowing him to maintain positional integrity and disrupt attacks without compromising defensive structure, while a short-passing buildup can leverage his technical skills.
The ability to adjust formations and tactics on the fly mid-match proves invaluable. Facing teams that exploit wing space might necessitate a shift to a 4-2-2-2, positioning midfielders to create quick passing combinations. Conversely, when opponents control the wings effectively, a switch to a 4-2-3-1 wide formation can centralize playmaking and facilitate link-ups with holding midfielders.
Separating tactical instructions for possession and defensive phases, along with specific Player Roles, adds another layer of strategic customization. Instead of simply assigning a player to a position, their role can be tailored to a specific contribution. For instance, a forward can be tasked with cutting inside for shooting opportunities or stretching the defense depending on the formation and game situation. This flexibility extends to defensive scenarios, where a player can be given more responsibility to support a fullback, bolstering a flank without sacrificing attacking structure.
The system excels at educating players on the strategic underpinnings of soccer formations, making the tactical aspect of the sport accessible to newcomers while still offering ample room for experimentation by experienced players.
Persistent Issues Linger
Despite the advancements in the Tactics system, some long-standing issues persist. The pathing and defensive logic of computer-controlled players can still falter on higher difficulties, undermining carefully constructed game plans. CPU defenders may fail to contest 50/50 balls or make inexplicable movements, while passing can still occasionally result in frustratingly inaccurate ball delivery to covered players.
On a more positive note, crossing and corner kick systems have seen noticeable improvements. These enhancements lead to more convincing positioning battles within the box and grant players greater control. The effectiveness of headed goals from corners, a rarity in previous entries, has significantly increased.
As the review process continues, further exploration of Career Mode, Presentation, Online, and Ultimate Team is planned to assess the full impact of the Tactics system on both single-player and multiplayer experiences before a final score is determined.