Elsinore, a film named for the castle central to Shakespeare's Hamlet, arrives in theaters on November 20th. Directed by Simon Stone, the movie stars Andrew Scott as Scottish actor Ian Charleson, known for his role in 1981's Chariots of Fire and his late 1989 stage performance as Hamlet. The film dramatizes Charleson's battle with AIDS and his treatment under Dr. Margaret Johnson (Olivia Colman), an early specialist in HIV/AIDS care.
The narrative centers on Charleson's drive to perform Hamlet despite his declining health. While Scott's portrayal of Charleson's doomed conviviality is noted as the film's primary strength and a likely awards contender, the surrounding elements struggle to elevate the material. Reviewers found the film to be blandly amiable, with supporting characters like Patsy (Billie Piper) and director Richard Eyre (Johnny Flynn) offering little dramatic opposition. Even Colman's character, Dr. Johnson, is described as more of an annoyance than a true antagonist.
A more significant challenge to Charleson comes from Derek Jarman (David Dawson), a fellow artist living with HIV. Jarman criticizes Charleson for not living openly as a gay man and for seeking mainstream appeal, which he views as a disservice to the community impacted by the disease. This conflict provides one of the screenplay's more impactful moments, offering a glimpse of Charleson as more than just a summary of his struggles.
Scott's performance is consistently praised for its precision and tenderness, particularly in scenes where Charleson rehearses and channels his anxieties into his Hamlet performance. However, the direction by Stone is criticized for its flat colors, uninspired cinematography, and an editing style that chops up important scenes, including stage performances, into montages. This approach is seen as undermining the lead actor's work and preventing key moments, like Charleson's final Hamlet performance, from playing out fully.
The critical consensus suggests that Elsinore functions primarily as a "performance delivery vehicle" for Andrew Scott. While his turn as Ian Charleson is commendable, the film itself lacks the artistic depth to stand on its own, failing to justify its existence beyond supporting Scott's awards aspirations.