Six weeks after the release of Magic: The Gathering's well-received Reality Fracture, players are now able to engage with the new Star Trek Universes Beyond set. While Universes Beyond sets often draw criticism for their themes, the crucial question for Limited players is how the set actually plays. Polygon's early access experience on Magic Arena with both Sealed and Draft suggests a significant departure from Reality Fracture.

Fast-Paced Gameplay

Reality Fracture was lauded for its midrange gameplay and the Empower Jace mechanic, which aided mana fixing and card advantage across all color combinations. In contrast, Star Trek Limited leans heavily towards aggressive decks designed to establish an early board presence. Even seemingly minor two-mana creatures can become problematic when paired with the set's numerous "pump" effects. For example, Sarcophagus, Ship of the Dead proved particularly impactful.

The Rakdos (red-black) Klingon decks showed promise, offering aggression backed by scarce removal spells, which often cost three or more mana or were sorcery-speed. Gruul (red-green) Landfall decks were also potent, capable of overwhelming opponents in the early turns. Polygon observed a turn 4 board state with nine power, potentially reaching 10 with a Planetary Patrol Landfall effect. A turn 5 attack, bolstered by removal and multiple Landfall triggers, reached 14 power, making recovery incredibly difficult for slower decks.

Difficulty in Turning Games Around

A significant negative impression from the early access period is how difficult it is to recover from a disadvantage in Star Trek Limited. Games felt one-sided, a common trait in aggro-focused formats where early momentum is paramount. This can lead to frustration and potentially shorten the format's lifespan.

This contrasts with Reality Fracture, which offered more balanced games that were often decided by incremental advantages built over longer turns, appealing to players who prefer a classic midrange playstyle. Polygon's own Golgari (green-black) graveyard deck, typically a favorite strategy, went 0-3 due to being too slow and lacking the ability to recover once the opponent gained an advantage. Flooding, or drawing too many lands, also proved to be a significant issue, even with Surveil cards, making comebacks nearly impossible.

While Star Trek is a large set with a diverse card pool that allows for multiple strategies, the emphasis on speed and the difficulty of recovery remain prominent. Polygon found success with a five-color Sealed deck that leveraged powerful cards and removal, but still struggled to survive long enough to deploy its bombs. Similarly, a straightforward Klingon deck with aggression, removal, and synergistic card advantage engines proved effective, highlighting red as a strong color in the format.

For players attending prerelease events, the advice is to focus on a solid mana curve, include plenty of creatures and removal, and be cautious with tapped lands, even when splashing colors with the available multicolored lands. Ultimately, the goal is to have fun.