Order of the Sinking Star Review: Ambitious Puzzles, Overwhelming Scope

A highly imaginative puzzle game offers significant fun, but its sheer size can prove daunting.

Oct 7, 2026
Reviews
Order of the Sinking Star Review: Ambitious Puzzles, Overwhelming Scope

Order of the Sinking Star presents a wealth of clever concepts and engaging design, leading to a deeply satisfying puzzle experience. However, the game's expansive nature can sometimes feel overwhelming.

The title excels in its myriad of smart ideas and well-crafted design elements, which combine to create many hours of enjoyable and thought-provoking puzzle-solving. Players will find themselves consistently challenged and rewarded by the intricate mechanisms and scenarios presented. The core gameplay loop is built upon a foundation of intelligent mechanics that encourage experimentation and discovery.

Despite these strengths, the sheer scale of Order of the Sinking Star is a double-edged sword. While the vastness offers a sense of depth and replayability, it can also lead to a feeling of being lost or inundated by the content. Navigating the game's large world and numerous puzzles may prove to be a significant hurdle for some players, potentially detracting from the otherwise positive experience.

Ultimately, Order of the Sinking Star is a game that achieves much through its ambitious scope and intelligent puzzle design. Its success in delivering fun and fascinating challenges is undeniable, but players should be prepared for a journey that can feel as daunting as it is rewarding.

Sources