Toy Story 5 arrives in theaters on June 19, bringing Woody, Buzz, and the familiar gang back for another adventure. This sequel to Pixar’s flagship franchise faces the challenge of justifying its existence, particularly after previous installments offered satisfying conclusions. The central question for this film is whether there is still room for more stories with these beloved characters, and if Pixar can successfully pull them out of the attic once more.
Visually, the film largely delivers on the Pixar standard. While not a revolutionary leap in graphics from Toy Story 4, the usual polish is evident. One early scene featuring an establishing shot of the sky, trees, and a school bus was so lifelike it momentarily convinced one young viewer they were watching live-action footage. For children, the appeal of such visual fidelity is straightforward, with one expressing it simply as "better grafics."
The film introduces a trio of new characters who proved to be a highlight: Mr. Smarty Pants, voiced hilariously by Conan O’Brien, a child-first digital camera named Snappy, and Atlas, a hippo-shaped map device. These characters not only provide memorable laughs but also engage with existential questions about their own purpose, a recurring theme that Pixar often explores effectively.
However, Toy Story 5 struggles with its core premise, particularly in its first half. The narrative feels weighed down by a sense of dread surrounding Bonnie's social isolation and her parents' attempt to help her connect with peers through technology. The introduction of a tablet, Lillypad, becomes a conduit for cyberbullying, prompting a discussion between the reviewer and his daughter about the role of technology and the nature of online interactions. This storyline, while modern, can feel less like an organic exploration of childhood and more like a directed commentary on "kids these days and their screens."
This focus on contemporary technology, while relatable to some, deviates from the universal themes of growing up, leaving home, or letting go that have historically grounded the Toy Story franchise. The film's critique of parental distraction, particularly a scene depicting a parent shouting "you're muted" during a Zoom call from a home office, resonates with the reviewer's own experience. Yet, the effectiveness of this critique is somewhat undercut by Pixar's own origins with technology like the iPad.
A Familiar Face, A Missed Opportunity
Woody, the franchise's iconic cowboy, feels particularly superfluous in Toy Story 5. His presence seems tacked on, lacking a significant plot function that impacts the narrative in a meaningful way. His story arcs often detract from the development of Buzz Lightyear, who is positioned as part of a potential two-hander with Jessie. Instead of allowing Buzz to explore new responsibilities or leadership roles, Woody’s return rehashes old dynamics, representing a missed opportunity for character growth.
The film significantly improves in its second half. The narrative becomes more adventurous, featuring well-choreographed action sequences and a more consistent comedic tone. Woody gradually recedes into a more comedic role, allowing the story to focus on more resonant themes such as forming meaningful connections and distinguishing between passive screen time and active play. The film eventually finds its footing, offering a stance on technology that, while not groundbreaking, feels necessary and provides a more satisfying conclusion.
Ultimately, Toy Story 5 delivers the visual spectacle expected of Pixar and introduces engaging new characters. However, its narrative struggles to find a contemporary relevance that matches the universal appeal of its predecessors. The film's exploration of screen time and social connection, while timely, doesn't always land with the emotional depth characteristic of the franchise, making its necessity as a sequel a lingering question.