Elden Ring, FromSoftware's vast and challenging action RPG, has resonated with players for its intricate lore, demanding combat, and expansive open world. However, for some, the game offers more than just a formidable adventure; it presents an unexpected space for queer identity and interpretation. While not explicitly stated by its developers, the game's narrative and character designs have allowed many players, including Eurogamer contributor Kelsey Raynor, to find a profound sense of inclusivity and representation within The Lands Between.
Raynor's initial experience with Elden Ring, her first foray into the Soulslike genre, was one of overwhelming difficulty. Yet, through perseverance, a new perspective emerged. The game, initially perceived as potentially exclusionary, began to reveal characters and relationships that challenged conventional norms. The presence of strong, imperfect female characters, alongside those who explore their identities and appearances, created a connection that transcended the typical dark fantasy setting.
Identity and Ambiguity
Central to Elden Ring's queer subtext is the complex relationship between Marika, the Queen of The Lands Between, and her consort, Radagon. Lore reveals them to be the same individual, sharing a body and warring over their existence after a personal tragedy. This internal conflict, a battle of identities and a struggle against an omnipotent entity known as the Greater Will, can be interpreted as an allegory for the trans experience. The clash between Marika and Radagon mirrors the challenges of identity and selfhood.
Further complicating the understanding of identity is Miquella, son of Marika and Radagon, and his alter-ego, St. Trina. The Sword of St. Trina's description itself highlights this ambiguity: "Some say she is a comely young girl, others are sure he is a boy." This gender-fluid character navigates an internal battle, and the narrative suggests that to achieve salvation, he must reconcile his differing selves. This theme of embracing all aspects of one's identity resonates deeply with queer players.
Even supporting characters like Dolores, the Sleeping Arrow Puppet, add to this tapestry. Described as a "spirit of a handsome archer who dressed in the style of a man," Dolores exemplifies how characters can present themselves in ways that defy traditional gender presentation, a theme that has historical roots in fiction and reality for reasons of safety, assimilation, or personal expression. The game leaves these motivations open to interpretation, allowing players to project their own experiences onto these characters.
A Step Forward in Representation
Compared to FromSoftware's earlier titles, Elden Ring represents a significant advancement in its handling of gender identity and sexuality. In Dark Souls 3, for instance, the NPC Anri of Astora's gender is fixed in opposition to the player's choice, and any eventual marriage is strictly heterosexual. Elden Ring, however, offers more fluid possibilities. The Age of Stars ending, which sees the player become the consort of Ranni the Witch, is attainable regardless of the player's chosen gender. Similarly, ascending to Elden Lord makes the player a consort to Marika/Radagon, irrespective of their character's gender.
While The Lands Between is a setting fraught with conflict and sorrow, it also portrays a world where same-sex relationships and diverse gender identities are normalized. The game explores various forms of love and devotion, from Rennala's grief over Radagon's abandonment and the unsettling devotion of Tanith to her slain lover, to the one-sided affection of Thiollier for St. Trina, and the unwavering loyalty of Cleanrot Knight Finlay to Malenia. These relationships, whether explicitly romantic or interpreted through a queer lens, contribute to the world's rich, albeit unconventional, romantic landscape.
Ultimately, Elden Ring's lasting appeal for many queer players lies in its openness to interpretation. The game provides a space where diverse identities are not only accepted but can be celebrated, allowing players to feel seen, valued, and empowered within its challenging world. It suggests that love, in all its forms, can coexist with chaos and brutality, making Elden Ring a unique and compelling experience for those who find themselves within its embrace.