Warning: This review contains full spoilers for Yaga Season 1, Episode 6. Episodes 1-6 are now streaming on AMC+ in the US and Crave in Canada, with new episodes releasing on Fridays at midnight PT. A trigger warning is also in effect for references to sexual assault and non-consensual behavior depicted in the series.
Yaga Episode 6 plunges into its darkest territory yet, offering answers while exposing horrifying experiences within the town of Whittock. The episode picks up following the dramatic arrival of Geena’s daughter, Lily, at Katherine’s door, visibly ill. Her subsequent treatment at the hospital reveals a harrowing sequence of events. Carson and Rapp learn that Lily experienced severe trauma, ingested hallucinogens, vomited blood, and was discovered to be eight weeks pregnant, though the pregnancy was subsequently terminated.
The gravity of Lily's situation is amplified by her age, 14. The truth emerges when Geena allows Carson into Lily’s hospital room: Henry raped Lily. A flashback details Henry, adorned with a floral crown, at one of his parties where Lily believes she was drugged. She recounts seeing Logan observing the encounter and Henry later dismissing her experience as mere drunkenness. Carson and Geena assure Lily that she is not to blame.
Following Lily's disclosure, Geena attempts to report the assault to the police, but Sheriff Eckert refuses to file a report. He later visits Geena's home, attempting to bribe her into silence with $50,000. Even after a sexual assault forensic exam is conducted, Eckert confronts Geena and Carson at the hospital, coercing them to leave. He physically assaults Geena, breaking her wrist and threatening further violence if the assault is reported. Geena confides in Carson that Eckert is on the Parks' payroll, expressing suspicion that the entire town may be complicit.
Further complicating matters, Lily reveals she discovered her pregnancy a week prior and underwent an abortion ritual the night before. Fearing the Parks' influence at the local hospital, she sought assistance from Pam, who directed her to Laney for a ritual at a secluded cabin. Flashbacks depict figures in witch masks in a clearing, with chanting and the presence of chickens and bones as Lily describes the ritual, which involved swallowing Henry’s tooth and drinking a chicken’s blood. Afterward, feeling unwell, she returned to town, stopping at Katherine's house.
Carson suspects Geena of involvement in Logan's death and potentially Henry's demise, drawing parallels to her own past trauma and her mother's desire for vengeance. Geena eventually admits, "Ya know, I wish I had killed both of them," expressing satisfaction at Logan's death and hoping Henry is also dead.
Rapp discovers Geena returned a rental car on the same day he checked his, finding a box with a podcast recording inside. Believing Geena left it for him, he breaks into her house. While on the phone with Carson, hearing Geena return startles Rapp, causing him to knock over a carton of eggs. Geena, hearing the disturbance, retrieves a shotgun from her closet. Rapp flees into the backyard, hiding behind a chicken coop. Geena fires a warning shot, and upon approaching, finds Rapp defending himself with a shovel. She then notices something on the ground behind him, a look of shock crossing her face. Rapp turns to see Henry's corpse in the chicken coop, castrated like Logan.
Eckert arrives and takes Geena into custody, while Henry's body is transported to the morgue. Later, Carson invites Rapp to her houseboat. He discusses his family's history of doing the Parks' dirty work. Rapp admits he had suspicions about Henry's character, despite viewing him as a younger brother, due to past incidents where the Parks paid to make problems disappear, though never involving a minor.
Carson alludes to Eckert's unwelcome advances the previous night, while grappling with his attempt to cover up Lily's assault. Rapp asserts that Geena did not kill Henry, citing her shocked reaction as proof she was unaware of his body's presence. The final episodes are expected to clarify whether Geena is being framed or is indeed responsible.
The episode concludes with Carson and Rapp sharing an intimate moment, hinting at a developing romantic connection amidst the unfolding drama. The narrator reflects on the theme of "witches without children," posing questions about Carson's potential pregnancy and the overarching narrative's direction. The episode, titled "Mother Witch," suggests the Baba Yaga figure and the masked witches may represent women protecting each other through extreme measures, potentially including Katherine, Yelena, and Pam.
Clark Backo's performance as Geena is highlighted as outstanding, setting the stage for a compelling two-episode finale. The episode is described as the most appalling and difficult to watch yet, while handling the sensitive subject of Lily's sexual assault with care.