Critical Role's tabletop role-playing game system, Daggerheart, has launched its first expansion, Hope & Fear. The nearly 200-page tome introduces new options for players and Game Masters, including four new classes, six ancestries and communities, over 100 pieces of gear, and a new Dread domain. For GMs, the expansion offers more than 130 new enemies, 28 environments, and four campaign frames.
Daggerheart is a narrative-focused system that utilizes a card-based character management system and forgoes traditional combat initiative. A core mechanic involves Hope and Fear dice, which determine whether players gain a 'Hope' resource for special actions or if the Game Master gains 'Fear' points to influence the game. The expansion's namesake mechanic, Dread, introduces intriguing effects, such as abilities that grow stronger with GM-held Fear or spells that reduce it, allowing players to directly counter the GM's influence.
Among the new classes are the Assassin and Brawler, which utilize existing domains, and the Warlock and Witch, which leverage the new Dread domain. New ancestries, comparable to species in other TTRPGs, include the winged Aetheris, various Elemental Kin (Earth, Ember, Sky, Tide), and Gnomes, notable for their Flicker Step teleportation ability. Some of these additions feel like staples that could have been included in the base game.
The expansion also provides flexibility for GMs with new campaign frames like Castle High, a modern wizard school setting, Reign of the Weredragon, and Journey to Horizon, which involves resurrecting a goddess.
A standout feature is the new Transformations system, allowing characters to become demigods, werewolves, vampires, or ghosts, each with associated bonuses and drawbacks. These transformations can add depth to characters and narrative arcs without consuming character or domain limits, though only one transformation is allowed at a time.
Daggerheart: Hope & Fear is described as a solid, if safe, first expansion. While it adds considerable content, it doesn't fundamentally alter the system's approach, which may still prove intimidating for players uncomfortable with improvisation. The reviewer notes that the expansion doesn't offer a simpler entry point for new players and suggests a starter set or more guided expansion could be beneficial for the system's growth. Despite this, the Dread domain and the Transformations system are highlighted as particularly exciting additions, with anticipation for future content that might further showcase the system's potential or provide a more accessible onramp for hesitant players.