Ti West’s Ebenezer aims for a darker, more horror-centric adaptation of Charles Dickens’ classic novella, and while it succeeds in creating an unsettling atmosphere, the film is ultimately hampered by Johnny Depp's overly theatrical performance as Ebenezer Scrooge.
The film embraces the inherent ghost story elements of A Christmas Carol, with West, known for his work in the horror genre, leaning into the story's spooky potential. The production design effectively captures the austere chill of Victorian London, with practical sets that immediately evoke the holiday setting. The destitution and gloom of the city highlight both Scrooge's aversion to poverty and his own spiritual bankruptcy. Tyler Bates' string-heavy score further enhances this unease, notably a driving and ominous rendition of "Carol of the Bells" accompanying the opening credits.
While largely faithful to Dickens' text, the adaptation by West and writer Nathaniel Halpern introduces embellishments to underscore Scrooge's internal conflict and the horror aspects. A new prologue featuring Jacob Marley (Ian McKellen) adds a somber opening and provides McKellen with more screen time. Expansions on Scrooge's difficult childhood and his failed engagement with Belle are handled with care, but Depp's detached portrayal of Scrooge prevents these additions from having a significant emotional impact. Despite its runtime of under two hours, the film's individual "staves" or acts tend to lose momentum before transitioning to the next.
The success of any A Christmas Carol adaptation hinges on the casting of its central figure. Johnny Depp's interpretation of Ebenezer Scrooge, characterized by broad physical actions and explosive emotions, feels more suited to a stage performance than the screen. This energetic and unpredictable performance, while lively, often feels out of sync with West's more grounded direction and the supporting cast's performances.
While Depp occasionally shows flashes of vulnerability, particularly in moments where he attempts to connect with his past selves or during the final redemption, these instances are overshadowed by his more manic approach. The film would have benefited from more restraint in his performance, allowing for a more accessible and human portrayal of the character. Depp is at his best when he allows for moments of reserve, making his eventual transformation more believable.
In contrast, the supporting cast provides much-needed grounding. Rupert Grint's affable portrayal of Bob Cratchit offers a warm counterpoint to Depp's Scrooge. Ellie Bamber as Belle and Sam Claflin as Scrooge's optimistic nephew Fred effectively embody the warmth and goodwill that Scrooge has rejected. Freddie Lee-Grey delivers a memorable performance as Tiny Tim, despite limited dialogue.
The spectral visitors in Ebenezer are depicted with a grim and unsettling demeanor. Ian McKellen's Marley serves a brief but crucial role in setting the stage for Scrooge's haunting, though the visual effects used to render him are described as cheap-looking and detract from his presence. This lack of quality extends to the numerous nameless ghosts that appear throughout the film.
However, the primary Ghosts of Christmases Past, Present, and Yet to Come are more effectively realized. Andrea Riseborough, as the Ghost of Christmas Past, is eerily effective with her detached demeanor and childlike voice, complemented by unsettling cinematography. Tramell Tillman's Ghost of Christmas Present is intense and impatient, conveying a palpable sense of unease. The Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come maintains its traditional silent, faceless presentation, augmented by a haunting clicking sound.
Ultimately, Ti West's Ebenezer is a respectable attempt at a horror-forward A Christmas Carol, but Johnny Depp's performance pulls focus and disrupts the film's overall coherence. While it may appeal to those seeking a spookier holiday film, its accessibility is compromised by the central performance, making it a tougher recommendation compared to more traditional or cheerful adaptations.
