S-Game's character action title, Phantom Blade Zero, is a game that excels in its core combat mechanics but is ultimately hampered by a convoluted narrative and frustrating design choices regarding quests. Kotaku’s 65-hour playthrough revealed an action game that leans more towards Ninja Gaiden than Soulslikes, blending intense, fast-paced combat with a sprawling world and a story that, while eventually engaging, is initially dense and difficult to parse.
Combat Delivers, Story Obscures
The standout element of Phantom Blade Zero is its combat. The game demands a constant balance of attacking, parrying, and dodging, offering little breathing room between enemy flurries. This “all-at-once” approach, initially disorienting, becomes a deeply satisfying and active experience that reviewer describes as potentially making it difficult to return to other action game combat systems. The tactile feel of pressing buttons to execute attacks and parries is consistently wonderful. Some of the boss fights are considered among the best in the genre, featuring intricate escalation and impressive aesthetics, such as a rival battle that transitions through multiple phases with a dynamically changing environment and music.
However, the game's narrative struggles to keep pace with its combat. The story is densely packed with unexplained proper nouns and lore, making the early hours a frustrating experience of trying to piece together a coherent plot. The worldbuilding, while eventually appreciated for its insights into the world's demise, is presented in an interruptive manner through numerous cutscenes, lore scrolls, and collectible audio logs. The story's climax, a 20-minute shadow puppet performance, is described as an ambitious but heavy-handed approach to pacing.
Design Choices Create Friction
Phantom Blade Zero's structure presents a world with numerous branching paths and environmental exploration. The design of standard enemy encounters, where defeated foes do not respawn, streamlines progression, turning the game into an exploratory boss rush. While this design choice prevents standard combat from becoming an insurmountable obstacle and avoids aggravating runbacks to bosses, it also diminishes the sense of stakes and challenge in regular encounters. The latter half of the game does introduce more challenging enemies with larger health pools, offering a more engaging combat loop, though this shift doesn't entirely resolve the earlier design issues.
Missable Quests and Endings
Significant frustration arises from the game's quest design. Phantom Blade Zero features a vast number of optional paths and side quests, some of which can span multiple chapters and have significant narrative implications, including access to the True Ending. The problem lies in how easily these quests can be missed. Progression can lock players out of questlines through simple factors like advancing too far without meeting certain criteria, making incorrect dialogue choices, defeating an unintended boss, or failing to pick up an item before talking to an NPC. The game often fails to provide adequate warning for these missable objectives. Given the game’s length, which can exceed 50 hours for a casual playthrough, missing a quest can effectively render it inaccessible for that playthrough, necessitating the use of a guide to experience all content.
Despite these criticisms, the game's soundtrack is noted for its inventive and eclectic mix of genres, including hip-hop, throat-singing, dubstep, rock, and Chinese opera, which coalesce into a unique and fitting score. Ultimately, Phantom Blade Zero is lauded as a fantastic game with incredible combat, but one whose overall potential is held back by narrative confusion and unforgiving quest design.